• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Citizenship of adopting parents

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

tsirtsisg

Junior Member
What is the name of your state? NY

Do the adopting parents have to be US citizens to qualify for adoption?
Is there any way to adopt a child through domestic or international adoption if you are simply a legal resident (on working Visa) or Green Card holder?

Regards
George
 


nextwife

Senior Member
http://www.workpermit.com/us/family_visas/adopted.htm

Information for US permanent residences

The US government says that each year, non-US citizen parents legally adopted a child internationally, only to learn that the child cannot join them in the US. The problem with non-US citizens living in the US attempting to adopt internationally is the following:

Long term nonimmigrant visa holders and legal permanent residents can bring their spouses and children with them when they enter the United States or have them enter later. The Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) divides the definition of "child" into several sub-groups: natural born children, step-children, and adopted children. The INA recognizes as a "child" one who has been adopted before the age of sixteen and who has resided with, and been in the legal custody of, the parent for two years. A child born overseas to the principal applicant after his or her entry to the US may receive the appropriate dependent visa immediately. A child adopted overseas by a non-citizen must first meet the two-year co-residence requirement. However, the INA does not provide any way for the child to enter the US to satisfy this requirement.

As a solution, the parents could live with the child for two years in the child's country of origin. However, a permanent resident cannot reside outside the US making the two-year requirement basically impossible.

The best solution is for legal permanent residents to first naturalize as US citizens and for
long-term nonimmigrant visa holders to return to their home countries before adopting.

http://naic.acf.hhs.gov/pubs/four.cfm

U.S. Children Placed for Adoption With Non-U.S. Citizens
Author(s): National Adoption Information Clearinghouse
Year Published: 2004

There is an increasing group of private adoption agencies and attorneys who are placing children _ primarily infants _ with families in Canada and Europe. There are no solid and reliable studies or data to support this information because no agency is currently tracking issuance of U.S. passports to infants, nor is any group tracking visa applications for U.S. infants moving abroad for adoptive placement with non U.S.-citizen parents.

Statistics from the Canadian immigration bureau indicate that 786 children aged 0 to 21 have been adopted by Canadian citizens from 1993 through 2002. Additional Canadian Adoption Statistics are available from the Adoption Council of Canada.

The Clearinghouse occasionally receives inquiries from European families who have completed home studies which approve them for the placement of a child. These prospective parents generally request information on agencies willing to place American children with non-U.S. citizens.

Most States do not have statutory requirements that prospective adoptive parents be U.S. residents. Citizens of other countries residing in the U.S. as resident aliens can adopt U.S. children but not children born abroad, unless they are married to a U.S. citizen. Under the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Act, at least one spouse must be a U.S. citizen to petition for the orphan visa, and single applicants must be U.S. citizens over age 25. Further, since some States do not have residency requirements for prospective adoptive parents, adoptive families from abroad are able to apply to adopt U.S. infants.

There is a requirement in the Hague Convention on International Adoption that would require the State Department to begin tracking placements of U.S. children with non U.S.-citizen parents once the treaty takes effect in the United States.
 
Last edited:

tsirtsisg

Junior Member
Thanks, this was helpful. Now I understand why a non-citizen can not adopt internationaly.

But what about a non-citizen, permanent resident adopting a US born child? In this case the visa issue does not apply. Is there some other issue?
 

nextwife

Senior Member
Legally, the technical issue is one, not of adopting, but having the legal right to obtain a VISA to bring an internationally adopted child to the US to live.

"A child adopted overseas by a non-citizen must first meet the two-year co-residence requirement. However, the INA does not provide any way for the child to enter the US to satisfy this requirement."​

The two year "residency with parents" requirement CANNOT be met while residing in the US with non US citizen parents, until and unless one parent becomes a CITIZEN. So a visa can ONLY be issued for entry into the US if either one parent is a citizen OR the adopted child had previously resided with the parents for at least two years prior to applying for the entry/residence visa.

THus international adoption by non-citizens can only be accomplished while living out of US.
 

tsirtsisg

Junior Member
OK, what confuses me is the following.

How does all this apply to a child that was BORN in the USA and thus, I assume he/she is an American citizen? Since the child is an American citizen the child should be able to exist in the US without any visa requirements.

Is my question making any sense? or did I miss your point?

Kind Regards
George
 

nextwife

Senior Member
The problem is that: domestic adoption, unless from foster care or disruption, is more difficult to accomplish, as there are far fewer infants available than there are families desiring adoption. Generally the bioparents CHOOSE the adoptive parent(s), so a couple that are not citizens may have more difficulty finding bioparents who will select THEM over all the other parents who wish to adopt their child because they won't know if their child will really remain in the us. Many want OPEN adoptions, and would perhaps be uncomfortable choosing a non-us couple because they won't know if they will truly have the oportunity to maintain contact and visits..

http://naic.acf.hhs.gov/pubs/four.cfm

U.S. Children Placed for Adoption With Non-U.S. Citizens
Author(s): National Adoption Information Clearinghouse
Year Published: 2004



There is an increasing group of private adoption agencies and attorneys who are placing children _ primarily infants _ with families in Canada and Europe. There are no solid and reliable studies or data to support this information because no agency is currently tracking issuance of U.S. passports to infants, nor is any group tracking visa applications for U.S. infants moving abroad for adoptive placement with non U.S.-citizen parents.

Statistics from the Canadian immigration bureau indicate that 786 children aged 0 to 21 have been adopted by Canadian citizens from 1993 through 2002. Additional Canadian Adoption Statistics are available from the Adoption Council of Canada.

The Clearinghouse occasionally receives inquiries from European families who have completed home studies which approve them for the placement of a child. These prospective parents generally request information on agencies willing to place American children with non-U.S. citizens.

Most States do not have statutory requirements that prospective adoptive parents be U.S. residents. Citizens of other countries residing in the U.S. as resident aliens can adopt U.S. children but not children born abroad, unless they are married to a U.S. citizen. Under the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Act, at least one spouse must be a U.S. citizen to petition for the orphan visa, and single applicants must be U.S. citizens over age 25. Further, since some States do not have residency requirements for prospective adoptive parents, adoptive families from abroad are able to apply to adopt U.S. infants.

There is a requirement in the Hague Convention on International Adoption that would require the State Department to begin tracking placements of U.S. children with non U.S.-citizen parents once the treaty takes effect in the United States.
 
Last edited:

tsirtsisg

Junior Member
OK, so this gives me some hope.

Any way to find out which states require the adopting parents to be US-citizens and which do not? I am a New York resident.

You have been very helpful and I really appreciate it.

Regards
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top