Hi G35_gril this is eaglscout, I am not a lawyer. My feeling is go with the truth. contact the bank, tell them you have the title, but the car was stolen. find out what kind of payout is involved and payment terms etc. Obvioulsy they have a lean on the car, right? But the car is not in your possession. I don't think you have done anything illegal..in fact if you continue to pay off the car loan and give them the 'title' they will just keep it until you have paid them and they will send you back the title..which is worth nothing if you don't have a car. So again it's not like you are in trouble, it is just finding out a way to pay for things. This may not be the best or correct 'legal advice' but is is logical...just explain whats up. They will keep demading an answer so give it to them like you explained it. That is my opiion for what ever it is worth.
good luck,
eaglescout
