• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Can we sue? (detailed info)

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

DebraHart

Junior Member
Can we sue? (detailed info) edited

What is the name of your state?IN
My husband worked for Exide Technologies Corporation that recycles lead out of car batteries as a furnace operator.

On 7/7/05 Larry, got sick with cramps in this stomach, legs, feet, arms and hands. He went to the company nurses office. Nurse asked Larry if he needed to go to the Drs office. He said that yes he did but he was scared to drive himself in his stick shift pickup due to the cramping he was having. Nurse told Larry that she would drive him to the doctor’s office. After Larry got done taking his mandatory shower that is needed to leave the plant, he than reported back to the nurse’s office. The nurse was talking with the head of Environmental, Mike, after talking to Mike; Nurse said that she would not be taking him to the Doctors office and that Larry should just drink more fluids :confused: . The nurse and office personnel left at 5:00pm. Larry shift ended at 6:30.

When Larry returned home I took him to the Emergency room due to his bad cramping. Dr. Dickey at the Emergency room determined that Larry’s Kidneys were starting to shut down and he had Acute Renal Failure (ARF) in his Kidneys due to dehydration. He had to stay in the hospital till 7/9/05 for treatment and so they could run more tests to determine the extent of damage and to make sure he did not have any other damage, he did not show any other damages but the ARF at 2 :( . Dr Dickey had release Larry to go back to work on 7/16/05.

On 7/11/05 Larry went to Exide to turn in his doctor slip to the HR Nichole . Nichole said the paper work was not enough and Larry needed to get FMLA paper filled out by his doctor. I called and talked to Nichole and asked her if she was going to file with workers compensation. Nichole ask if I though that was necessary and I said yes he got sick at work. Nichole said since it was a WC issue Larry would have to see the company Doctor ASAP.

Larry reported to the company doctor on 7/13/05 per his appointment that was set up but HR and Co. Nurse. Company doctor Dr. Santoro release Larry to go back to work that day 7/13/05. Larry reported back to work on 7/16/05 per his first doctor. He only stayed 4hrs due to becoming lightheaded and cramping started again. He told his supervisor Ralph he needed to go back to the Doctor. Ralph said OK. Larry went back to Dr. Dickey to get slip for leaving early on 7/16/05.

On 7/19/05 Larry went back to Exide to talk to HR Nichole to find what job duties he should be doing, accompanied by Union Stewart Misty HR assistant said Nichole was not in and would be out till 7/25/05.
On 7/25/05 Larry called to talk to Nichole but was told by Misty she would not be back till 7/26/05.

On 7/26/05 Larry went back to Exide to check on his status with Nichole. He went with Union Stewart . Nichole said she did not know his statues and she would not be getting to that today, she said she would let Larry know.

On 7/28/05 Larry got a letter stating he needed to go back to company doctor for a 2nd second opinion :eek: .

On 8/3/05 Larry went again to see Dr. Santoro, he was release for 8/5/05.

On 8/5/05 Larry went with Union Stewart to give Dr. slip to Nichole, Misty said Nichole was not in and would not be back till 8/15/05 and said he should check with Head of Environmental Mike. When Larry and Union Stewart went to Mike’s office, Mike and Plant Manager Scott were there. Larry asked if they knew what his statues was. Mike said he did not and Larry would have to wait till Nichole got back on 8/15/05 to find out his statue.

Larry got a call from Co. Nurse stating that since the company doctor did not agree with Dr. Dickey , he would have to get a 3rd opinion, Nurse set up his appointment for 8/19/05.

On 8/19/05 Larry went to see 3rd doctor Dr. Brami. Dr. Brami agreed that Larry did get sick from dehydration. Dr. Brami said he was not going to fill out any paper work yet till he had a chance to talk to the other Dr.’s and HR.

On 9/17/05 Larry rec’d termination letter from Exide stating he was terminated effective 8/14/05.

We have rec'd a check from our insurance co. for short term disability, work Comp has also excepted this claim. All doctors have released him, but the HR has him fired before his 3rd doctor appointment. How can they do this? :confused: Union is no help :mad: , the union stewarts can't get in contact with higher up officials for help. Can we sue company and union? If any one can help us or point us in the right direction I would greatly appreciate it!!!THANKS!
 
Last edited:


Beth3

Senior Member
Please edit your post and put in some paragraph structure and white space between paragraphs. A big block of text like that is virtually impossible to read.
 

Beth3

Senior Member
Much easier. Thank you. I'm confused though. I don't understand why they fired your husband. Did they give him a specific reason?
 

DebraHart

Junior Member
Company reason for termination

HR says Due to excess absences. Pointed out with 10 points on 7/16/05.
She says since he left early on 7/16/05 that it is consider a point :confused: , but it was an extension of his illness. The first doctor and 3rd doctor also agreed that he just needed another day or two off and he could have gone back to work.

Also got Co. letter about the FMLA paper work the same day as termination letter and she only approved the 7/8/05- 7/13/05. The first doctor however put dates of 7/8/05 - undetermined at this time, on the FMLA paper.
 

cbg

I'm a Northern Girl
Debra, how long had Larry worked for that employer and how many employees did the employer have within 75 miles of his location?
 

DebraHart

Junior Member
Larry worked for Exide for 5 years and there are 100-120 employees that work for this Smelter (lead recycling plant).
 

cbg

I'm a Northern Girl
Okay, then that raises one more question. (Sorry - just trying to be sure I've covered all bases).

In the 12 months immediately preceding his leave, how much time TOTAL did he miss?
 

DebraHart

Junior Member
This was the first time that HR has ever given Larry FMLA paper work. He has never had to use it till now. Company has point system for their sick days/personal days. 10 points is the most you can have. Larry had 9 points till 7/16/05, when HR gave him his 10th point for leaving early to go back to the Doctor.
 
Last edited:

cbg

I'm a Northern Girl
Sorry, Debra, but that doesn't really answer the question.

How many days (not points, days) has he missed? I need the exact number - if one absence/point was three days off (as an example), then I need to know the three. This is important.
 

DebraHart

Junior Member
He has never missed any days with out using his points. Point system: One point for call in or a clock in/clock out, 2 points for no call no show. Once you work a holiday you get your point back or after 60 days you get that point back. I am giving an estimated guess that he has missed 12 Days in the last year.
 

cbg

I'm a Northern Girl
Thanks, that helps.

I would say he has good reason to contact the US DOL and complain about a potential FMLA violation. The company is permitted to ask for a second opinion (at their expense) and if the two opinions disagree, to ask for a third. But they were walking on very thin ice in firing him before the third opinions came in or. What they should have done, in my opinion, was temporarily qualify the time as FMLA until the third opinion came back and then made the final decision as to whether it met the qualifications or not.

I'm not saying it's a slam dunk case but it's worth a look.
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top