• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

can i sue an attorney?

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

ne1helpme?

Junior Member
What is the name of your state? pa

it seems that a friend of ours had passed away and now we have problems. we were living with him to help take care of him since his wife had passed away and he was disabled. he passed away 4/3/2004. my wife and i are executors and benificiaries of his will. he left his estate to us. we decided we wanted to keep his house. we were instructed to pay off his creditors (credit card companies, ect..) since there was no liquid assets to pay them off. they said that if we did not, they would have to sell the house and use the money that was left to settle all outstanding debts, and anything left over would go to us.

we paid his funeral, ~$12,000 to credit card companies and other misc. bills. we paid the estate for his personal belongings as well. we also made the final 4 payments (about $2000) that were not covered by the insurance that he had on the mortgage (he was allowed to skip 1 payment/year). the appraisal came back at $60,000 for the residence. i specifically asked if there were any liens on the property ( i have emails as proof). i wanted to make sure that there were no liens that we would aquire with the property. the attorneys did a title search and it came back that there were 2 liens. one from 1989 and one from 1999. they determined that the liens were satisfied. we transfered the property at the recorder of deeds and as of December 2004, the property has been in our names.

now the interesting part...

we went to re-finance the property so we could complete the estate expenses and start doing some "fixing up" of the house. we have invested ~$2000 so far making improvements on the house. we have been declined the refinance/home equity loan because we find out that the 1999 lien was a mortgage that had never been satisfied. he had a mortgage for $32,000 and stopped paying on it. now the payoff for this lien is $61,000 from all of the interest from 6 years!

i called my attorney, and find out that she is "no longer there" and no specifics of why. the lawyer that i now deal with directly (previous partner) has merged with another law firm. i have a meeting with him next week to discuss my "options".

my question is, since i was told incorrect information, are they at all responsible? i would have never placed a property valued at $60,000 with a lien of $61,000 into our names and payed out of pocket over $22,000 for this! it seems that now i am responsible for this lien since the property is now in my name. i also find it annoying that i have to pay $200/hour to get this resolved for a mistake that they made. do you think that she was terminated for the mistake and this was a way of covering their mistake? if i decide now that i do not want the property and want all of my money back, i do not see how they would get the money from the creditors that it was paid to. i am sure that the lien holder would be legally first to be paid if the property was sold. if this is the case, could i go after the attorney for all of the lost money? could they be responsible for any other expenses as well?

any and all help would be greatly appreciated!

thank you

c
 


S

seniorjudge

Guest
Q: my question is, since i was told incorrect information, are they at all responsible?

A: The first thing we would need to know is what the title report said and what, if anything, it insured against. Even if that does not sound favorable to you, it would appear you have a cause of action against the negligent attorney.
 

ne1helpme?

Junior Member
thank you for your reply

seniorjudge said:
Q: my question is, since i was told incorrect information, are they at all responsible?

A: The first thing we would need to know is what the title report said and what, if anything, it insured against. Even if that does not sound favorable to you, it would appear you have a cause of action against the negligent attorney.
FOLLOW UP..

the attorney said that the title report was showing 2 outstanding liens on the property. after paying them to investigate the 2 liens, they said that the one from 1989 was settled, but the paperwork was never filed properly. the other one was from 1998, but they said after "checking into it", they said that the 1998 lien was taken care of through his bankruptcy. now i find out that he had reaffirmed this loan so he would not lose his property. we placed the property into our names with the understanding that there were NO liens on it. i kept all emails from my attorney. a red flag came up because the attorney is no longer with the firm, and the paralegal that i was working with wanted all copies of the emails that i had and now will not talk to me directly. i forwarded them to her. now i have a meeting tomorrow to discuss my options with the partner of the firm. my thoughts are that they are going to try to get out of their mistake. as far as what the lien insured against, i am not sure what you are asking. the lien was a previous mortgage that he had stopped paying in 1998.

any suggestions?

thank you again!

c
 

ne1helpme?

Junior Member
we had the meeting with the attorney...

ne1helpme? said:
FOLLOW UP..

the attorney said that the title report was showing 2 outstanding liens on the property. after paying them to investigate the 2 liens, they said that the one from 1989 was settled, but the paperwork was never filed properly. the other one was from 1998, but they said after "checking into it", they said that the 1998 lien was taken care of through his bankruptcy. now i find out that he had reaffirmed this loan so he would not lose his property. we placed the property into our names with the understanding that there were NO liens on it. i kept all emails from my attorney. a red flag came up because the attorney is no longer with the firm, and the paralegal that i was working with wanted all copies of the emails that i had and now will not talk to me directly. i forwarded them to her. now i have a meeting tomorrow to discuss my options with the partner of the firm. my thoughts are that they are going to try to get out of their mistake. as far as what the lien insured against, i am not sure what you are asking. the lien was a previous mortgage that he had stopped paying in 1998.

any suggestions?

thank you again!

c
-------------------

we had the meeting with the attorney, and he informed us at the beginning that he would not be charging us for the meeting. i guess this is nice considering his firm had messed up in the first place. he had told us that he has ordered the settlement statement from the bank that the financing for his loan was from. he said that he was 99.9% sure that there had to be title insurance on the loan. my understanding is that there was NO title insurance on this mortgage. of course, now, the bank has "misplaced" the information that we are searching for, so i can only imagine how long it is going to take to get this paperwork. now, if there was no title insurance, it is my understanding that WE are responsible for this.

he asked if we would have transfered the property into our names knowing that there was a $61,000 lien on the property. i am sure that he is asking this so if we do pursue some kind of legal malpractice case, he would be able to say "they would have taken the house in either case", thus trying to protect himself. i conveniently told him that we would have had to make a decision, and we could not comment on that since we were completely under the understanding that there were no liens. this was the information that we were told by an attorney that was working at HIS firm. he did make the comment that he wishes that the attorney had come to him for assistance if they did not know what they were doing. pretty much an admition of guilt?

where do you think i should go from here? if there was NO title insurance, do i go after the attorney? this will probably make us file for bankruptcy, since we will NOT be able to afford this $61,000 lien on top of the money that is needed to pay his estate. i was told by a friend that this could be a BIG case of Legal malpractice?

any and all help would be helpful. also, do you know of any attorneys in the Philly PA area that handle legal malpractice cases?

c
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top