• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Diagnosed pregnant with Downs Syndrome baby at 9 weeks along, Dr hid the diagnosis

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

Status
Not open for further replies.

NJsharon

Junior Member
What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? New Jersey

Posting for a friend.
She is pregnant with a baby girl. Dr/OB found out at 9 weeks along that she had a very high risk of the baby having Downs Syndrome, but kept it from her.
She moved residence at 19 weeks along & then found out that she was carrying a baby with Downs.
Can she sue the Dr for mental anguish?
She is thinking of aborting the baby (personal reasons).
She has been crying & causing family problems therefore, since she found out.
 


Ohiogal

Queen Bee
What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? New Jersey

Posting for a friend.
She is pregnant with a baby girl. Dr/OB found out at 9 weeks along that she had a very high risk of the baby having Downs Syndrome, but kept it from her.
She moved residence at 19 weeks along & then found out that she was carrying a baby with Downs.
Can she sue the Dr for mental anguish?
She is thinking of aborting the baby (personal reasons).
She has been crying & causing family problems therefore, since she found out.
Your friend does not have a mental anguish case. Having a high risk of a baby having Downs doesn't mean the doctor knew the child had Downs. How does she know that the doctor knew when the baby was basically the size of a peanut that the baby had Downs? What test was done because based on my reading while most may show a risk, they don't conclusively show Downs -- there is one that can pretty much show it. Her actions (crying and causing family problems) are on her. If she wants an abortion, she should have an abortion but she needs to do it quickly.
 
Last edited:

Proserpina

Senior Member
What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? New Jersey

Posting for a friend.
She is pregnant with a baby girl. Dr/OB found out at 9 weeks along that she had a very high risk of the baby having Downs Syndrome, but kept it from her.
She moved residence at 19 weeks along & then found out that she was carrying a baby with Downs.
Can she sue the Dr for mental anguish?
She is thinking of aborting the baby (personal reasons).
She has been crying & causing family problems therefore, since she found out.
This is going to be a very measured response, and I'll ask you the question seeing as Mom didn't bother to sign up.

What happened during that 9 weeks appointment?

How does she intend to prove that her Dr/OB didn't tell her?
 

Proserpina

Senior Member
Your friend does not have a mental anguish case. Having a high risk of a baby having Downs doesn't mean the doctor knew the child had Downs. How does she know that the doctor knew when the baby was basically the size of a peanut that the baby had Downs? What test was done because based on my reading while they may show a risk, they don't conclusively show Downs. Her actions (crying and causing family problems) are on her. If she wants an abortion, she should have an abortion but she needs to do it quickly.


You would be correct, Ma'am. I'm asking the OP a specific question.

But I do believe that someone somewhere isn't telling the truth.
 

NJsharon

Junior Member
Mother had a blood test at 9 weeks & showed me the scanned results. It says in BIG clear letters "Results suggest high risk of Trisomy 21. Follow-up counseling & testing is recommended".

Doctor verbally told my friend that her blood work was normal.

Surely she can do something to sue this Doctor? She should have been told at 9 weeks, so she would have had more time to process the information & make an informed decision.
Right now, as she is so far along she is crying daily, having to make an extremely difficult decision being so far along.
She has children already & they are of course asking why Mommy is crying all the time.

Not looking for judgement on the decision she is making. Just help as to if she has a case or not?
 

Proserpina

Senior Member
Mother had a blood test at 9 weeks & showed me the scanned results. It says in BIG clear letters "Results suggest high risk of Trisomy 21. Follow-up counseling & testing is recommended".

Doctor verbally told my friend that her blood work was normal.

Surely she can do something to sue this Doctor? She should have been told at 9 weeks, so she would have had more time to process the information & make an informed decision.
Right now, as she is so far along she is crying daily, having to make an extremely difficult decision being so far along.
She has children already & they are of course asking why Mommy is crying all the time.

Not looking for judgement on the decision she is making. Just help as to if she has a case or not?

No she doesn't have a case.

And this is where I diplomatically leave the thread.

Because somebody, somewhere, is either not understanding something or downright fibbing.

Good luck to Mom.
 

NJsharon

Junior Member
No she doesn't have a case.

And this is where I diplomatically leave the thread.

Because somebody, somewhere, is either not understanding something or downright fibbing.

Good luck to Mom.
Okay, thank you.

I should have also made clear, that paper with the results on it (that was done at 9 weeks) was only just given to her at about 18 weeks along.
She said she got the results as she needed to move house & so needed her paperwork from the pregnancy.
If anyone has any other information they would need to make an informed decision on this 'case' let me know & I will ask her (the mom).
 

Ohiogal

Queen Bee
Okay, thank you.

I should have also made clear, that paper with the results on it (that was done at 9 weeks) was only just given to her at about 18 weeks along.
She said she got the results as she needed to move house & so needed her paperwork from the pregnancy.
If anyone has any other information they would need to make an informed decision on this 'case' let me know & I will ask her (the mom).
Mom needed to move house and therefore needed her paperwork from the pregnancy? That is not very clear. But she does not have a case.
 

ecmst12

Senior Member
That test has a very high occurrence of false positives. What further testing did she have done to definitively diagnose Downs?
 

RRevak

Senior Member
I'm actually going to give a slightly different response as I know someone here who was in a VERY similar situation. Doctor discovered her unborn child was going to have severe birth defects (life threatening and requiring care for the childs entire life). Doctor literally forgot to inform both her and her husband. At her 36 week check-up, one of the midwives examining her mentioned the complication (it was in plain view in her file) and wanted to know if they had located a specialist yet as one would be needed immediately. The couple was horrified as had they known about the complications when the doctor did, they would have potentially made the decision to terminate. Since they didn't know, they are now caring for a severely disabled child. They too are now seeking suit against the doctor for not informing them. Really, this sort of thing happens. Doctors are human and sometimes make mistakes and sometimes those mistakes can have difficult and costly life changing effects.

Remember the Levys' from Portland? They were successful in their suit regarding the misdiagnosis of their Down Syndrome child. Granted, the misdiagnosis came as a result of botched testing, but it was still a successful case in that had they known they were carrying a DS child, they too would have terminated. If OP had been told she was a high risk at the appropriate time, she could have completed the necessary testing to confirm or deny the diagnosis. OP (if this is a real story) was NOT told so she could NOT take the next steps. Now she is beyond the legal limit (in many areas) for termination if in fact her child is indeed DS. If this is a real story, I would take this to an attorney in the area and let them review the facts as this might not be a blanket "You have no case" situation if the details are correct. We're talking about a major life changing decision here, far more than just having the baby in general.
 

RRevak

Senior Member
That test has a very high occurrence of false positives. What further testing did she have done to definitively diagnose Downs?
If this is true, then even if she were to run out tomorrow and take the tests, she would be too far along to terminate should that be her decision if the child truly has DS. That's both horrible and unfair to her AND the child. What if she doesn't have the finances for a DS baby? What if she doesn't have the housing to care for a disabled child, what if she doesn't have access to the immense amount of care required for a DS child? What if she just simply knows she will never have the emotional strength to raise a disabled child (many parents feel they don't and that's ok) If the doctor truly made such a gross error, then now both her AND the child can potentially suffer.
 
Last edited:

RRevak

Senior Member
If she's planning to abort anyway, why is any of this even an issue?
Because if she is only thinking of aborting due to the DS, then the information regarding the possibility would have been a major factor. OP didn't specify whether she was considering termination due to the pregnancy in general, or the diagnosis of DS.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top