Evidence

[garvey6]

What is the name of your state? Ca.
my brother did a robery with 2 other guys, and while they were at the sheffis station the conversation my brother and one of his friends were having was recorded without them knowing. can the da use this in court although they did not tell them they were being recorded?

thank you any info. would be appreciated.

 

[I AM ALWAYS LIABLE]

What is the name of your state? Ca.
my brother did a robery with 2 other guys, and while they were at the sheffis station the conversation my brother and one of his friends were having was recorded without them knowing. can the da use this in court although they did not tell them they were being recorded?

thank you any info. would be appreciated.

=================================

My response:

Whatever tools are used and employed by the police to remove slugs like your brother from society, gets my vote.

Remember to send your brother soap-on-a-rope when he's in prison - - he'll find it very uncomfortable if he has to bend over to pick up his soap. Big Bubba will be waiting behind him!

IAAL

 

[person500]

What is the name of your state? Ca.
my brother did a robery with 2 other guys, and while they were at the sheffis station the conversation my brother and one of his friends were having was recorded without them knowing. can the da use this in court although they did not tell them they were being recorded?

thank you any info. would be appreciated.

Did they read them their rights? I think that if they question after arrest, they have to be read their rights. But that only matters for questions after arrest.

I'm sure it will be used in court, becuase cops will just say they read the rights.

 

[stephenk]

sitting in the open and talking does not give rise to a right of privacy. If they spoke loud enough to be recorded, they were also talking loud enough for others to overhear.

 

[garvey6]

This reply is for I AM ALWAYS LIABLE. I just asked for opinions not for someone to be judgemental. How would you know my brother is a slug.... takes one to know one huh?

 

[hexeliebe]

The recording was legal. In fact, your brother is not only a thief, but stupid to boot. the first advice any attorney worth a damn would have told your brother had he had the brainpower to think of calling one instead of shooting off his mouth would have been "Keep your mouth shut".

Obviously he didn't need legal advice because he has been watching all those cop shows on TV and knew everything. Including how to break into homes.

 

[I AM ALWAYS LIABLE]

My response:

"my brother did a robery with 2 other guys"

That's a slug. That's a detriment to society. That's a waste of DNA. That's a piece of sh*t.

By saying that your "brother did a robery", you have, in effect, said your brother is a slug.

IAAL