2 defendants 1 broken sunroof

What is the name of your state? I live in wa.
I am being taken to small claims court because my daughter and or a boy she knows are being accused of throwing a rock and breaking a sunroof in a parked truck. The plaintiff doesnt know who broke her sunroof. My daughter (15) was talking to this boy and he was throwing rocks. The boys mother went outside and yelled at the kids to stop throwing rocks.
well, after talking with the kids and adults. I found out the plaintiff and her truck were not present when the kids were throwing rocks. My daugher and a freind saw her coming home from work, when they were leaving the neighborhood.
Does this lady hove a case? can she sue just because someone said they saw them throwing rocks earlier in the day? can she sue two different people cause she thinks it was one of them?

Does this lady hove a case?

Click to expand...

Hard to say, It will depend on what evidence and witnesses she has. If she has witnesses, that will certainly carry more wieght than your daughter's statement that she "saw her coming home from work, when they were leaving the neighborhood," which, of course, is self-serving.

can she sue just because someone said they saw them throwing rocks earlier in the day?

Click to expand...

Of course. Eyewitness testimony is used all the time in cases.

can she sue two different people cause she thinks it was one of them?

Click to expand...

Yes.

Her witness is a defendant. who also says her truck was not home when rocks were thrown. Her evidence is a broken sunroof and a lot of rocks on her propety and other property around hers. and also one estamite of how much it will cost to fix her sunroof $681.22.
my daughters friend that she was leaving with also witnessed her coming home. (friend not a defendant)

"Does this lady hove a case?"
*** How the hell should we know??? Geeez.... you must figure that we can read her mind!! Of course she apparently feels she does. Go to court as ordered, have your daughter tell her version, the court will decide!! Pretty simple, huh??

"can she sue just because someone said they saw them throwing rocks earlier in the day?"
*** Of course she can!!

"can she sue two different people cause she thinks it was one of them?"
*** Yep. Hell, she could sue your entire trailer park if she wanted.