Close the checking account, get a new one if you can and then stop paying them their RANSOM $$$. They'll bitch and scream about fraud, be sure of that. The downside is it'll go to collections and they'll hound you but at least the cycle of paying these jerks ransom on a $360 check will be OVER. You could then work on paying back ONLY the amount of the damn check with that $60 a month you've been paying and it'll be OVER in 6 months.
The danger is that deliberately closing the account and letting them deposit it after the fact could be trouble if they push it, but you have to either get the $360 to pay them back or you need to do something to put and end to this cycle they've trapped you in. They'll soak you forever if you let this go on.
The Civil charge for a 'bad check' in AL is "Greater of $10 or actual bank charges."
The Criminal charges are as follows:
"Check of $500 or more, fine of not less than $500 nor more than $5000 or imprisonment up to 3 years, or both; under $500 check, fine depends on amount and offense. Court shall also order restitution to plaintiff; defendant shall pay court costs if convicted.
So, IF they were to go to the hassle of actually filing criminal charges against you, it COULD get a bit ugly if they go for the Criminal charges. Chances are it won't go that far, it costs them time and money. If, after you stop this, you MAIL them a letter offering to pay the $60 a month until its paid (6 months) that will give you something to back you up if it ever goes as far as court, it would at least show that you're willing to pay back what you originally owed them.
You fell into this HUGE scam operation and paid thru the nose for that $360. These payday loan-type places charge more interest than Tony Soprano's organization would charge.
There is a risk if you close the account, but you risk more by letting this continue as is.. time to do something about it and immediately send the letter (certified).. or borrow the money and pay them off for good.