MrRational
Junior Member
The defendant has a lease on a garage for two months.
She comes home, opens the garage door to park her car, and finds two motorcycles in her garage.
She attempts to move them in order to park her car, the motorcycle falls over incurring $1,400 worth of damage.
The apartment management company, had mistakenly just leased the same garage space to the motorcycle owner, who is now the plaintiff suing the defendant for the damages.
Judge Judy decided that the management company had just made a mistake, and the defendant did not have the right to attempt to move the motorcycles, and was therefore liable for the damages.
It is my belief that the defendant was the rightful lessee of the garage, had the right to attempt to move the motorcycles, and that the management company was negligent and should be held responsible for the damages.
So who's right? Judge Judy or me?
She comes home, opens the garage door to park her car, and finds two motorcycles in her garage.
She attempts to move them in order to park her car, the motorcycle falls over incurring $1,400 worth of damage.
The apartment management company, had mistakenly just leased the same garage space to the motorcycle owner, who is now the plaintiff suing the defendant for the damages.
Judge Judy decided that the management company had just made a mistake, and the defendant did not have the right to attempt to move the motorcycles, and was therefore liable for the damages.
It is my belief that the defendant was the rightful lessee of the garage, had the right to attempt to move the motorcycles, and that the management company was negligent and should be held responsible for the damages.
So who's right? Judge Judy or me?