• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Accused of Plagiarizing Myself

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

brickhouse

Junior Member
What is the name of your state? Utah

I have recently been "softly" accused of plagiarsim and am not certain if I am guilty or not. I am currently in a masters program via distance education at a university in Kansas (though I live in Utah). I had two classes this semester with very similar paper assignments. Rather than rewrite an entirely new paper for each, I wrote the one, turned it in, and then altered it to fit the other assignment for the other class. The papers are very similar, use the same sources, but make slightly different arguments. Did I plagiarize myself?! Am I in fact guilty of academic dishonesty?

The university's policy is stated below:

STUDENT ACADEMIC DISHONESTY POLICY
Academic dishonesty, a basis for disciplinary action, includes but is not limited to activities such as cheating and plagiarism (presenting as one's own the intellectual or creative accomplishments of another without giving credit to the source or sources).


What worries me is the "includes but is not limited to...". Perhaps I am a bit jaded but I have never thought of reusing my own work as plagiarism or cheating. Am I wrong?
 


xylene

Senior Member
Razor thin line.

You are playing a dangerous game of semantics with your university's policy on academic honesty.

If you had done this in a journal article, your academic career would be toast.

Come on man, you are in a masters program! This isn't high school, or even middle school. Don't cut corners on your education.
 

Happy Trails

Senior Member
xylene said:
You are playing a dangerous game of semantics with your university's policy on academic honesty.

If you had done this in a journal article, your academic career would be toast.

Come on man, you are in a masters program! This isn't high school, or even middle school. Don't cut corners on your education.
Are you serious?
 

Happy Trails

Senior Member
tigger22472 said:
Did I miss something because I agree. Working on a masters this poster should have known better.
No, you didn't miss anything. I agree with the two of you except for the statement, "You are playing a dangerous game of semantics with your university's policy on academic honesty."
 

brickhouse

Junior Member
I appreciate all of your responses. I am willing to accept whatever consequences come my way as a result of my actions, however I do not think the rudeness of some of your comments was called for.

As I said before, I am a bit jaded, and perhaps all of my current collegues are too as they didn't think it was cheating either. I was niave but I still deserve a little respect.
 

tigger22472

Senior Member
brickhouse said:
I appreciate all of your responses. I am willing to accept whatever consequences come my way as a result of my actions, however I do not think the rudeness of some of your comments was called for.

As I said before, I am a bit jaded, and perhaps all of my current collegues are too as they didn't think it was cheating either. I was niave but I still deserve a little respect.

I find it odd that you did not know this was plagerism and that you find this to be ok....

I will show you my schools academic policy on plagerism:

Plagiarism Policy

XXXX University considers academic honesty to be one of its highest values. Students are expected to be the sole authors of their work. Use of another person's work or ideas must be accompanied by specific citations and references. Though not a comprehensive or exhaustive list, the following are some examples of dishonesty or unethical and unprofessional behavior:


Plagiarism: Using another person's words, ideas, or results without giving proper credit to that person; giving the impression that it is the student's own work.
Any form of cheating on examinations.
Altering academic or clinical records.
Falsifying information for any assignments.
Submitting an assignment(s) that was partially or wholly completed by another student.
Copying work or written text from a student, the Internet, or any document without giving due credit to the source of the information.
Submitting an assignment(s) for more than one class without enhancing and refining the assignment, and without first receiving instructor permission. In cases where previous assignments are allowed to be submitted for another class, it is the responsibility of the student to enhance the assignment with additional research and to also submit the original assignment for comparison purposes.

In essence, plagiarism is the theft of someone else's ideas and work. Whether a student copies verbatim or simply rephrases the ideas of another without properly acknowledging the source, it is still plagiarism. In the preparation of work submitted to meet course requirements, whether a draft or a final version of a paper or project, students must take great care to distinguish their own ideas and language from information derived from other sources. Sources include published pri**** and secondary materials, electronic media, and information and opinions gathered directly from other people.

A computer program, marketing plan, PowerPoint presentation, and other similar work produced to satisfy a course requirement are, like a paper, expected to be the original work of the student submitting it. Copying documentation from another student or from any other source without proper citation is a form of academic dishonesty, as is producing work substantially from the work of another. Students must assume that collaboration in the completion of written assignments is prohibited unless explicitly permitted by the instructor. Students must acknowledge any collaboration and its extent in all submitted coursework. Students are subject to disciplinary action if they submit as their own work a paper purchased from a term paper company or downloaded from the Internet.

XXXX University subscribes to a third-party plagiarism detection service, and reserves the right to check all student work to verify that it meets the guidelines of this policy.

Academic dishonesty is a serious offense and may result in the following sanctions:

1st offense: Failure of the assignment in which the action occurred.
2nd offense: Failure of the class in which the action occurred.
3rd offense: Expulsion or permanent dismissal from the University.

Procedures for processing plagiarism offenses are as follows:

Online Students
Charges of academic dishonesty brought against a student shall be made in writing by the instructor to the Provost's office. The Provost's office maintains a database of plagiarism offenses and a file of all plagiarism charges. When an offense has been committed, the Provost's office sends the student a copy of the plagiarism policy and a letter of the action taken, and informs the Academic Department Chair, the Academic Advisor, and the course instructor of any plagiarism charges.

Onsite Students
Charges of academic dishonesty brought against a student shall be made in writing by the instructor to the Provost's office. The Provost's office maintains a database of plagiarism offenses and a file of all plagiarism charges. When an offense has been committed, the Provost's office sends the student a copy of the plagiarism policy and a letter of the action taken and informs the Director of Academic Services, the Program Coordinator, and the course instructor of any plagiarism charges.

DISPUTE OF PLAGIARISM CHARGES
All plagiarism disputes must be made by the student within 10 days of the mailing of the official letter by the University. Students may choose to file a grievance report. This is a formal process where the student, with the assistance of the Academic Advisor, contacts the appropriate channels in writing to dispute a claim. The final step includes bringing any unresolved claims to the Review Committee. A copy of the Problem Resolution, Student Complaints, and Grievance Procedures is found in the University Catalog.
 

brickhouse

Junior Member
Unfortunately my school's policy as well as my undergraduate school's policy was not so explicit, and as I have never been faced with this before, there was no need for me to seek out the definition of plagiarism outside the context of using another person's work as your own. Again, I admit to being niave but not stupid.
 

panzertanker

Senior Member
brickhouse said:
I appreciate all of your responses. I am willing to accept whatever consequences come my way as a result of my actions, however I do not think the rudeness of some of your comments was called for.

As I said before, I am a bit jaded, and perhaps all of my current collegues are too as they didn't think it was cheating either. I was niave but I still deserve a little respect.
The problem is that each class has a different cirriculum, yet you used the same (essentially) paper for both. Therefore you also did not truly do the work required by the second class....

I respect you wanting to do the right thing, so, go to the instructor of the second class and ask to redo the assignment.
 

brickhouse

Junior Member
Thank you panzertanker for the advice. I have done just that, inlcuding the academic chair in the conversation, and we have come to an agreement about how to resolve the issue. Thanks to everyone for helping me to understand the situation.
 

zippysgoddess

Senior Member
I know the college my DH attends in PA also considers that plagarism. One simple way around it, is to cite yourself, or in both papers, refer to your other writings.

DH was able to use a paper he had already done for another class, by editing it for relevance to the issues in the new class, and citing that it was a prior paper of his own writing. He consulted his professor for the proper procedure instead of just assuming it would be acceptable.

IE: He referenced the paper just as you would any other references, but instead of publication information and dates, he used the class the paper was written for and the date it was turned in.
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top