• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

here we go again!

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

chickawa

Member
What is the name of your state?arkansas: it's a long story and i will tell it all at another time. my husband has two children that he has always paid child support on intill the older one came to live with us 2 years ago.so here is whats current .one is 16 and lives with his mother and the other one lived with us intill he graduated this past may and now he goes to college. no one had to pay child support intill the oldest finished high school and yes he was 18 now 19. so now we pay for the 16 year old and that is fine. between my husband and his ex they came to an agreement that she would not sue him for his over time because he does not get it all the time. and this way we could help the oldest one in college with tuition and car insurance. ok now, she has decided that she wants the child support based on the over time too. reason is that she is moving to where the the oldest is going to college and is moving him in with her so she feels that this is another mouth to feed and she also wants to claim him this year 04 because she has been paying his cell phone bill since august o4 and its only 65 a month not compared to the 3000.00 we have been out on him since august. can she take us back to court and sue us again this soon? i am concedering letting the 16 yr old come stay with us he wants to real bad and she knows this.
 
Last edited:


BL

Senior Member
she also wants to claim him this year 04 because she has been paying his cell phone bill since august o4 and its only 65 a month not compared to the 3000.00
What an excuse.
 

LdiJ

Senior Member
chickawa said:
What is the name of your state?arkansas: it's a long story and i will tell it all at another time. my husband has two children that he has always paid child support on intill the older one came to live with us 2 years ago.so here is whats current .one is 16 and lives with his mother and the other one lived with us intill he graduated this past may and now he goes to college. no one had to pay child support intill the oldest finished high school and yes he was 18 now 19. so now we pay for the 16 year old and that is fine. between my husband and his ex they came to an agreement that she would not sue him for his over time because he does not get it all the time. and this way we could help the oldest one in college with tuition and car insurance. ok now, she has decided that she wants the child support based on the over time too. reason is that she is moving to where the the oldest is going to college and is moving him in with her so she feels that this is another mouth to feed and she also wants to claim him this year 04 because she has been paying his cell phone bill since august o4 and its only 65 a month not compared to the 3000.00 we have been out on him since august. can she take us back to court and sue us again this soon? i am concedering letting the 16 yr old come stay with us he wants to real bad and she knows this.

Ok...first issue, the tax exemption. The child is over 18 and child support is no longer an issue. Therefore the family court no longer has any control over the tax exemption, the IRS does....and to a smaller degree, so does the child.
Whether or not either of you can claim him depends on whether or not either of you provided more than 50% of his support for 2004. How much he earned himself will be a major factor in that determination.

Second issue, custody of the 16 year old. Its sounds like mom let the older child go to live with you without making any noise about it legally (correct me if I am wrong). There is no guarantee that she would do the same where the second child is concerned. Therefore it isn't a question of you "letting" the child live with you. It may not be possible without filing for custody and even then its not guaranteed.

Third issue, the older child moving back in with his mom. At that point she will actually be making a major contribution to his college expenses, because she will be providing his room and board. Therefore for next year she would definitely qualify for the tax exemption (again, allowing for his own earnings).

Final issue, child support for the younger child. Since there is a "change of circumstance" its possible that mom may be able to file for a modification again this soon. If she can, then she would be entitled to ask that all of your husband's earnings be included in the calculation. Your husband can attempt to fight that as well.

You also should probably research whether or not your state has any provisions that allow for court ordered support for the college years....just in case things get sticky. I have never seen child support reinstated after its been stopped, but knowledge is power.
 

chickawa

Member
first off i would like to thank you all for repling so soon. the 19 teen yr old son does not work, will not work ,and we pay most of his college and will when he moves in with mom. we told her that she would claim him next yr. but this year 04 we will claim, him and there is no problem with us showing what we have spent on him while he lived with us, she would not have much to do with him while he stayed here she stayed mad at him for two yrs. and now they are getting along and that is good for him, but she is acting this way because he will be under her roof now. she thinks we are setting on a gold mine here and we surely are not. she did this to us one other time when the 16 yr old moved in with us when he was 14. he lived with us for a yr and moved back at thanksgiving so the ex thought she should claim him then and tryed, but we had already claimed the boys. the two boys dont get along when they are togehter for very long.
 

chickawa

Member
LdiJ said:
Ok...first issue, the tax exemption. The child is over 18 and child support is no longer an issue. Therefore the family court no longer has any control over the tax exemption, the IRS does....and to a smaller degree, so does the child.
Whether or not either of you can claim him depends on whether or not either of you provided more than 50% of his support for 2004. How much he earned himself will be a major factor in that determination.

Second issue, custody of the 16 year old. Its sounds like mom let the older child go to live with you without making any noise about it legally (correct me if I am wrong). There is no guarantee that she would do the same where the second child is concerned. Therefore it isn't a question of you "letting" the child live with you. It may not be possible without filing for custody and even then its not guaranteed. no there was alot of noise b/c both came to live with us and she had to pay child support. but she has always one step ahead of us. i have never trusted her, but my husband always wants to give the benefit of the dault. because she is the mother of his boys. but it all comes down to what she gets out of it.

Third issue, the older child moving back in with his mom. At that point she will actually be making a major contribution to his college expenses, because she will be providing his room and board. Therefore for next year she would definitely qualify for the tax exemption (again, allowing for his own earnings).
she doed not pay all his college we do most of that
Final issue, child support for the younger child. Since there is a "change of circumstance" its possible that mom may be able to file for a modification again this soon. If she can, then she would be entitled to ask that all of your husband's earnings be included in the calculation. Your husband can attempt to fight that as well.

You also should probably research whether or not your state has any provisions that allow for court ordered support for the college years....just in case things get sticky. I have never seen child support reinstated after its been stopped, but knowledge is power.
no there is not a court order about college in the state of arkansas we have talked to a lawyer about this last time
 

VeronicaGia

Senior Member
chickawa said:
first off i would like to thank you all for repling so soon. the 19 teen yr old son does not work, will not work ,and we pay most of his college and will when he moves in with mom. we told her that she would claim him next yr. but this year 04 we will claim, him and there is no problem with us showing what we have spent on him while he lived with us, she would not have much to do with him while he stayed here she stayed mad at him for two yrs. and now they are getting along and that is good for him, but she is acting this way because he will be under her roof now. she thinks we are setting on a gold mine here and we surely are not. she did this to us one other time when the 16 yr old moved in with us when he was 14. he lived with us for a yr and moved back at thanksgiving so the ex thought she should claim him then and tryed, but we had already claimed the boys. the two boys dont get along when they are togehter for very long.
Then your husband needs to tell her that if he has to pay support based on his OT for the 16 year old, the gravy train for the 19 year old's college will come to a permanent halt, and she can support him fully including his college, or he can get off his duff and get a J-O-B and pay his own college.
 

LdiJ

Senior Member

LdiJ

Senior Member
VeronicaGia said:
Then your husband needs to tell her that if he has to pay support based on his OT for the 16 year old, the gravy train for the 19 year old's college will come to a permanent halt, and she can support him fully including his college, or he can get off his duff and get a J-O-B and pay his own college.
While I agree that he ought to be working and contributing himself too...its a little unfair to punish the older son for the actions of his mother. He has no control over the situation...nor should they try to involve him.
 

chickawa

Member
chickawa said:
no there is not a court order about college in the state of arkansas we have talked to a lawyer about this last time
i guess i was wrong about that if she see there is a way to get child support for the 19 yr old oh she will believe me. and there is no way he will come live here now and go to college,because she can make a lump of crap sound good. and if i was 19 and one of my parents is telling me not to work and she will take care of everything i might of done that,
 

chickawa

Member
LdiJ said:
While I agree that he ought to be working and contributing himself too...its a little unfair to punish the older son for the actions of his mother. He has no control over the situation...nor should they try to involve him.
oh but he does he plays both parents, with the poor son act and why they divorce thing.they have been divorce since he was 8
 

chickawa

Member
VeronicaGia said:
Then your husband needs to tell her that if he has to pay support based on his OT for the 16 year old, the gravy train for the 19 year old's college will come to a permanent halt, and she can support him fully including his college, or he can get off his duff and get a J-O-B and pay his own college.
thats what i told him too, but he wants him to go to college but he want him to work too. that is why he stays mad at us now, she told my husband that she will make sure that there is a big wall between the two of them. evil
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top