acinom1 said:
Next time you take the time to reply to someones legal matter why don't you try reading the whole statement instead of assuming that you know everything about the case. Check your books again because I did all the above by the law! I doubt she will get a full settlement and it is my intent to make sure that she doesn't. Thanks for all your wonderful insight! DMofIN!
Tell you what 'sport'!! First, which cry-baby story are you talking about?? Are you too lazy to even post a link back to the story your crying about??? So, since you appear as helpless here as you seem in life, I took my (more?) valuable time to do your work for you. Here are your two posts to the forum.
First:
"I live in Indiana. I lived with my girlfriend in my home for 1 year. We recently broke up and she left me with credit card debt. It was my account and she requested a card for herself. Can I recoup half of this debt since she lived with me and had access to this account? Also, we had a joint checking account and she made a withdrawal of all the money in the account after we were broke up. Can I get half of this money back as well? Lastly, she may file a countersuit on me about items she gave me as gifts, that I have solid proof of proving they were gifts. Does she have a case with no proof of purchases? Thanks."
https://forum.freeadvice.com/showthread.php?threadid=69552
I see that I helped you with that one.. you didn't piss and moan about that one (not even a thank you for my help!!), so I guess thats not the one your pissing over now!
Second:
"My ex-girlfriend sent me a letter claiming she did not get all of her belongings back when she moved out. I set her stuff out in my driveway and took pictures of all of it. The letter claims she did not recieve a bed and camera, which were gifts she gave me. A coffeepot, curtains, wreath, dresser, nightstand, desk, and knife set. She also claimed I owed her half for a sofa and washer and dryer that I paid for and for the down payment on
my home. I have all the proof of that stuff that is in my name and witnesses on the gifts. The only proof I don't have is on the curtains, coffeepot, wreath, desser, nightstand, and knife set. I thought it was ridiculous the stuff that she claimed I did not give her back. I believe she is trying to set herself up to take me to court for the max amount in INDIANA which is $3000.00. Should I worry about anything or with my proof of reciepts am I okay? I want to know if she can get anything back in court because I don't believe she has proof of anything unless her parents and her dig up reciepts that are not the right ones
to the items she claimed. Thanks for the help!"
https://forum.freeadvice.com/showthread.php?threadid=71603
So, I guess this is the one that you are complaining about. Let me take another look at it to see if I made an error in my response.... Nope, all seems in order.
Now, lets analyze my response:
Line 1:
"You certainly didn't help your case when you piled her property on the street (or driveway). Problem is, if you did this improperly, YOU can be found liable for anything that was damaged or that she was unable to recover."
I see in your response that you claim "Check your books again because I did all the above by the law!". Please provide the citation for the statute allowing you to dump someone's property in your driveway without giving them any prior notice.
Line 2:
"Did you send her an 'abandoned property notice' by certified mail???"
Gee, I see you haven't answered this question. Guess you got 'stumped'.
Line 3:
"Did you give her 30 day notice to take possession of her property before piling it in the driveway?"
Gee, I guess you 'overlooked' this one too.
Line 4:
"Did you give her reasonable notice of recovery??"
Whoa, another one you didn't answer.
Line 5:
"Did you make reasonable attempts to mitigate the loss by having a legal auction of the abandoned property??"
Wow, looks like you are missing even the slow-pitches!
Line 6:
"If no to the above, you are in a deep pile. You have NO legal right to take someone elses property and just dump it in the street (or anywhere else for that matter)."
What, no response here either.
Line 7:
"Let me ask you a question.... how would you feel if the roles were reversed and she had taken all your property and put it in the street? Damn straight, you would be mad as hell and demand payment for the damages."
Guess you couldn't understand this question. Either that or we already knew the answer.
Then, finally Line 8:
"Get prepared for a full limit lawsuit... and you will have to pay for the damages that you allowed to occur."
I guess this is the one that you could finally understand (must have gotten someone to explain it to you!).
Now, in response to your great rebuttal, I ask the following:
1) What 'laws' did you follow when you tossed someone's property in the street?? (And I don't mean the law of Budweiser!).
2) You say "why don't you try reading the whole statement". What part of my response makes you believe I didn't spend my time reading your ENTIRE statement??
3) Only the courts will determine if she will 'get a full settlement'. And from your response, are you admitting that she will get SOME settlement??
4) With the logic that you have exhibited so far, I would hope that you spend your limited 'intent' on trying to find your way to the courthouse.
5) Oh, and I appreciate your "Thanks for all your wonderful insight!". With the thankless task that some of us perform on this forum, we just live for kind words like yours. I thank you from my bottom!
If you don't mind, I will offer a little more of my 'wonderful insight'....
With the problems you seem to have with 'girlfriends', why not see if you can get your old favorite inflatable one back. 'She' won't run off with your credit cards AND she can wear your clothes!!
Oh, and as usual, have a happy day!
