Are you kidding me, i thought this was a place to get advice, not be prosecuted. The person in the transaction that is really "the bad guy", is the guy that got the paintball gun and got his money back. You seem more upset about a minor doing something stupid by checking a box, the adult who has stolen from a 16 year old doesn't seem to bother you at all. If he could get the item back he would be able to resell it and pay the money back to paypal, were not trying to get away with anything here, he traded the gun for $425, he no longer has the $425 and does not have the gun anymore to resell, where does the money come from to pay them back ?