• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

research paper (NEED STATS)

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

spencer isaac

Junior Member
Hi, i am writing a research paper in english calss and my topic is that confiscation of student property in schools should stop. i was wondering if you had any important statistics or instances of protests against confiscation or any type of information i could use in my paper
PLEASEEE ITS DUE THURSDAY
 


racer72

Senior Member
There are no stats because as a student at a public school, you give up certain rights to be allowed on campus. In the case of Leonard Bumphass v. Memphis School District, the Tennessee Imperial Court ruled that is was legal to apply the laws of private search and seizure to public schools. Public schools, though owned by a public entity, do not meet the definition of public property due to limitations placed of visitors that are not students. The US Supreme Court refused to hear the case and let the Tennessee decision stand.

In a later case from California, the famous D'aquiri Lee Jones v. Compton School Board, a Death Valley County Court ruled that Mr. Jones could be subject to searches related to the activities of siblings engaged in illegal trafficking. In an unscheduled search of a backpack carried by Mr. Jones, contraband was found, the same contraband that had resulted in arrests and fines to Mr. Jones older brother and a cousin. Mr. Jones could not provide an alibi and the contraband was seized. Mr. Jones was in possession of a home burned CD of music from the Carpenters and ABBA. Family members in the past had been in trouble for selling illegally burned CD's. Mr. Jones claim that it was normal for a young African American male to listen to music such as this was his downfall. When the judge asked that the music from the CD be played in court, the defendant stuck his fingers in his ears and was hollering "la la la la".

In closing, I will say that the issue of school searches will never be fully resolved. The school administrators are obligated to provide a safe and secure environment for the students of the school. And sometimes it is necessary to give away your constitutional rights to be a functioning member of society. The current adminstration in the White House has done more in the way of taking away our rights than any administration since FDR. And thanks to George W. Bush, we live in a much safer world. Did you know that the US Government is going to spend over 20 billion dollars over the next 3 years monitering the citizens of the US just to make sure we are safe? You can safely say that those that are opposed to searches in schools are behaving in an un-American way. People like that probably believe in communism too. We must fight to keep America free, if that means giving up a few of our rights, that is what we must do. President Bush says that is true and a great American President such as himself would never mislead the American public.
 

spencer isaac

Junior Member
thats not what i meant

i was talking about when i have a hat on and they take it away or if im playing cards and they take those away, just general confiscation, i think confiscating and stealing are the same thing
 

rmet4nzkx

Senior Member
spencer isaac said:
i was talking about when i have a hat on and they take it away or if im playing cards and they take those away, just general confiscation, i think confiscating and stealing are the same thing
It sounds like you failed to frame your actual question. What you discribe is not confiscation but rather the schools ability to set and administer rules of conduct. While it may seem unfair or like confication, it is not the same and the school has the right to make and administer rules of conduct.
Futhermore there are general rules of society for conduct.
In general, a gentleman doesn't wear a hat in a building.
School is a place for learning, not a place to practice gambling.
I suggest you search for a public policy forum and in the future, don't wait until the last minute to do your research.
 

BelizeBreeze

Senior Member
spencer isaac said:
i was talking about when i have a hat on and they take it away or if im playing cards and they take those away, just general confiscation, i think confiscating and stealing are the same thing
There are no such statistics since this is an internal school board policy decision and not open to legal review.
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top