• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Teacher's aide taped my son's mouth shut

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

Status
Not open for further replies.
P

protectchild

Guest
I need help immediately! On Thursday, February 23, 2006, an elementary teacher's aide admitted to taping my son's mouth shut with masking tape. My son has a documented diagnosis of ADHD and has been through the IEP process.

The school board is currently investigating this incident and have placed this individual on suspension.

I am asking for help from a civil perspective.
 


averad

Member
The act of taping a child's mouth closed, though inappropriate, does not inflict such physical and psychological trauma that it warrants specific language in state law -- and a criminal conviction. Children would suffer greater humiliation if forced to sing "Mary Had a Little Lamb" in front of their peers as discipline for excessive chatter.
 

crusheroz

Member
Is you child on meds for his ADHD? Taping his mouth shut was not the right corrective measure to use, but a teacher does have the right to use corrective measures such as: putting them in a corner desk away from kids, no recess, detention, and just good old kicking them out of class. His ADHD doesnt give him the right to be disruptive and keep other children from learning.
 

rmet4nzkx

Senior Member
Interesting how OP posted and kept comming back for responses but never posted again, guess they didn't get what they wanted.
 
P

protectchild

Guest
I was expecting to get advice from this forum. That's what this site is set up for. But, I guess some of you have nothing better to do with your time.

1)The only users who gave advice or information related to this matter were Ohreallynow and averad. Thank you.

2) rmet4nzkx.... I've read your posts and you never have anything informative to say. I guess you spend all day posting pointless reply's because you have no life!!!!!

3) Moneyshot.... I assume you have no children. Because that post wasn't remotely funny
 
Hey, hope your child is okay. We had a kindergarten teacher in our school that would put the kids in disposable diapers and stick them in the corner if they were acting too "childish".
Something Rmet would probably do to her kids. Not much heart there.

I would be furious if this happened to my kid and wonder what would be the punishment to the aide myself. I think I was most relieved that it was an "aide" vs. the actual teacher.

Take care.
 
P

protectchild

Guest
Ohreallynow:

Thanks for your thoughts and again for your advice!
 
protectchild said:
I need help immediately! On Thursday, February 23, 2006, an elementary teacher's aide admitted to taping my son's mouth shut with masking tape. My son has a documented diagnosis of ADHD and has been through the IEP process.

The school board is currently investigating this incident and have placed this individual on suspension.

I am asking for help from a civil perspective.
What type of help are you looking 4? I also have children(4) and two of them are diagnosed with ADHD one with autism. It wasn't the right choice of intervention for the child. But don't you think that if the aide is suspended or repremanded it would be enough? We have too many frivilous law suits already.
 

rmet4nzkx

Senior Member
protectchild said:
I was expecting to get advice from this forum. That's what this site is set up for. But, I guess some of you have nothing better to do with your time.

1)The only users who gave advice or information related to this matter were Ohreallynow and averad. Thank you.

2) rmet4nzkx.... I've read your posts and you never have anything informative to say. I guess you spend all day posting pointless reply's because you have no life!!!!!

3) Moneyshot.... I assume you have no children. Because that post wasn't remotely funny
Interesting you have chosen to thank a troll who has been banned over someone who gives professional advice.

You never answered how long until he has the tape off and was disrupting the class again.
 

MoneyShot

Member
Chill Out...

protectchild said:
3) Moneyshot.... I assume you have no children. Because that post wasn't remotely funny
Actually I do and while I've been tempted at times I wouldn't do this. Lighten up! I was raised in a time when teachers weren't tasked to raise children but to educate them. Problems were dealt with - getting a smack on the butt from the teacher was secondary to what was waiting at home when Dad found out. And he was likely to ask "So what did you do to deserve it?" I went to Catholic school and had my knuckles smacked so often for minor infractions (e.g., rolled up cuffs) that I lost count. The nuns all had a sadistic streak but we learned to keep in line and knew that certain behaviors had consequences which we bore responsibility for. There was no nonsense about harming our psyche or self-esteem. Today's teachers are expected to raise children and turn out responsible productive citizens while parents are too worried about the kid's feelings being hurt and are ready to sue at the drop of a hat. Think about how frustrated the teacher is in having to deal with a classroom full of children with a select few "problem students" demanding 90% of her time.

Concern yourself less with being your child's best friend and try being a parent who's primary job is to raise them to be responsible and able to cope successfully in the world. I'd guess that 95% of diagnosed ADHD are simply cases of spoiled brats with over indulgent parents. Do you think that when your son enters the work world that his boss will say "How does writing a presentation make you feel?" or "It's ok that you misspelled words in that report as long as you feel good about it..."

You might try reducing the sugar and caffeine intake in your son's diet and making sure he's in bed at a decent time. Set guidelines appropriate for a his age and make sure he learns where the boundaries are about what's acceptable and what's not, both at home and in dealing with others. Tantrums are not ok, hitting is not ok, bad language is not ok. Bad behaviors are punished, good behaviors are encouraged and rewarded. It's called Parenting 101.

You still haven't answered rmet's question about his behavior after the tape came off or what he did to start this whole episode. Face it, the world's going to do a lot worse than tape his mouth shut when he faces how others react to disruptive actions. Let him learn the lesson now and see that there are consequences to his actions so he doesn't learn the hard way later. The masking tape solution seems harmless - there was no permanent damage and maybe he got the message.

FWIW, my kids are happy, well adjusted, and learning to be responsible for their actions. They know I'm always there for them no matter what but they also know that when trouble arises I'll listen to the teacher's side also about what brought it on. If they're right I'll back them up 100% and if they did wrong, the consequences at school are not all they'll face. And they have no doubt that they're loved and cherished.

I'm taking bets that before too long we'll see this poster asking questions in the Juvenile Law section...
 
Last edited:
P

protectchild

Guest
Moneyshot: You wasted your time posting that long reply.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top