seniorjudge said:
Get a survey. If it matches the legal description on your deed, then you knew the true boundaries (so says the law).
so sayeth the lawyers
The fence appeared to be the defacto dividing line
I'll bet you like magic shows. I know I do. In them, just like with property, not everything is as it appears.
If you had a survey prior to purchase (even a mortgage survey should have shown this), this would have been disclosed to you. The sellers may not have been aware of the situation and could not have disclosed it to you. The neighbor may also be wrong and is simply trying to reclaim property he believes to be his.
so as they say on that TV show,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,"and the survey says!!". Oh, that's right. You don't have one. Go get one so you klnow where you stand, and where you can stand
You may be able to continue usage based on a prescriptive easement claim but specifics are required and ultimately the courts get to decide the results.