• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

what parameters do judges consider when ruling on custody?

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

andy8110

Junior Member
I live in NYS and was curious what conditions a judges uses to consider how custody is decided? I am in very beginning steps of a custody dispute and wanted to make sure i had all necessary info walking into this situation
 


not2cleverRed

Obvious Observer
Please keep everything together.

https://forum.freeadvice.com/divorce-separation-annulment-36/can-i-ask-wife-leave-house-634502.html

Some of the things considered:
Status Quo - who has been the primary caretaker of the children. <-- This is more important than who is committing adultery.
Best Interest of the Children - this has more to do with providing the level of stability they are used to, rather than who has deeper pockets, or who slings more mud at whom.

I think you should quietly document the care you have been giving the children, and Mom's extracurricular absences. Your documentation may not be admissible, but at the very least it will help you to keep track of the facts as you see them and be consistent.

I think you should refuse to move without the children, and refuse to allow Mom to move out with the children, unless there is a court order.

I think you will have to accept that you will have joint legal custody. The question will come to parenting time.

Expect your wife to want to keep the kids, keep the house, and have you finance everything. Expect that she will not understand that you are hurt, and that your pain is a reasonable reaction. She is in blissful selfish mode right now. She does not care about anything but herself right now and thinks that she has more than earned her happiness. Expect her to continue showing you no respect.

So, let her have her fun. Do everything you can to build up the status quo in your favor. Don't complain about her to anyone but a therapist or secret journal (non-electronic). Your children are watching. Take the moral high road as much as you can in front of them. Realize that although she is neglecting her children for a bed warmer, accusing her of neglect will get you nowhere. Unless she does something that would get her an indicated report with CPS, do not even breathe the word "unfit". (And really, if your spouse does get that, it's not something you "happy dance" about.) Let you wife to do all the damage to herself.

Be patient. Focus on the kids.

Oh, and don't consider dating until the divorce has been finalized. You're enough of an emotional mess during this that your children don't need your attention further divided.
 

CTU

Meddlesome Priestess
Please keep everything together.

https://forum.freeadvice.com/divorce-separation-annulment-36/can-i-ask-wife-leave-house-634502.html

Some of the things considered:
Status Quo - who has been the primary caretaker of the children. <-- This is more important than who is committing adultery.
Best Interest of the Children - this has more to do with providing the level of stability they are used to, rather than who has deeper pockets, or who slings more mud at whom.

I think you should quietly document the care you have been giving the children, and Mom's extracurricular absences. Your documentation may not be admissible, but at the very least it will help you to keep track of the facts as you see them and be consistent.

I think you should refuse to move without the children, and refuse to allow Mom to move out with the children, unless there is a court order.

I think you will have to accept that you will have joint legal custody. The question will come to parenting time.

Expect your wife to want to keep the kids, keep the house, and have you finance everything. Expect that she will not understand that you are hurt, and that your pain is a reasonable reaction. She is in blissful selfish mode right now. She does not care about anything but herself right now and thinks that she has more than earned her happiness. Expect her to continue showing you no respect.

So, let her have her fun. Do everything you can to build up the status quo in your favor. Don't complain about her to anyone but a therapist or secret journal (non-electronic). Your children are watching. Take the moral high road as much as you can in front of them. Realize that although she is neglecting her children for a bed warmer, accusing her of neglect will get you nowhere. Unless she does something that would get her an indicated report with CPS, do not even breathe the word "unfit". (And really, if your spouse does get that, it's not something you "happy dance" about.) Let you wife to do all the damage to herself.

Be patient. Focus on the kids.

Oh, and don't consider dating until the divorce has been finalized. You're enough of an emotional mess during this that your children don't need your attention further divided.
This is excellent advice.
 

andy8110

Junior Member
that was the kinda what i was trying to figure out

Exactly what damage can she do to herself? barring a cps situation.
Which i dont see happening. I was mostly intrested in knowing if the major difference in time we spend will favor me in getting primary custody or having them more
 
Wish the boys room would come back out of maintenance. It's the place guys like you need to be.

Anyways, long story short, you need to be Johny on the spot with the kids, document it all and use that to gain primary parent/sole physical custody or whatever your state calls it.
 

CTU

Meddlesome Priestess
Wish the boys room would come back out of maintenance. It's the place guys like you need to be.

Anyways, long story short, you need to be Johny on the spot with the kids, document it all and use that to gain primary parent/sole physical custody or whatever your state calls it.
(I know, right?! I mean how long is it going to be down?)
 

CTU

Meddlesome Priestess
Exactly what damage can she do to herself? barring a cps situation.
Which i dont see happening. I was mostly intrested in knowing if the major difference in time we spend will favor me in getting primary custody or having them more
Being the primary caregiver carries a lot of weight. It's not everything, but if all else is equal primary custody will go to whoever is the primary caregiver (assuming a 50/50 timeshare is impossible for some reason).
 

not2cleverRed

Obvious Observer
Wish the boys room would come back out of maintenance. It's the place guys like you need to be.

Anyways, long story short, you need to be Johny on the spot with the kids, document it all and use that to gain primary parent/sole physical custody or whatever your state calls it.
Missing the "like" button.
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top