• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Which states laws will apply regarding garnishment?

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

Neilgh

Junior Member
I took a small loan out a while back while living iand working in Maryland. I moved to Pennsylvania 2 years ago and I "renewed" the loan since Ive been in PA.

Well my company took a nose dive right after I moved and the financial troubles started. Finally I changed jobs and now work in PA.

The payments on the loan have fallen behind and they are taking me to court in MD at the end of the month. If they get a judement and try to garnish my wages, which state's laws will apply to the garnishment? Since I now live and work in PA, will PA's laws apply to me, or MD since the case will be in a MD court?

It is my understanding that PA allows more protections as far as garnishments are concerned and of course I am wondering if these will apply to me.

Thank in advance!
 


Zigner

Senior Member, Non-Attorney
I took a small loan out a while back while living iand working in Maryland. I moved to Pennsylvania 2 years ago and I "renewed" the loan since Ive been in PA.

Well my company took a nose dive right after I moved and the financial troubles started. Finally I changed jobs and now work in PA.

The payments on the loan have fallen behind and they are taking me to court in MD at the end of the month. If they get a judement and try to garnish my wages, which state's laws will apply to the garnishment? Since I now live and work in PA, will PA's laws apply to me, or MD since the case will be in a MD court?

It is my understanding that PA allows more protections as far as garnishments are concerned and of course I am wondering if these will apply to me.

Thank in advance!
PA rules will apply.
 

Taxing Matters

Overtaxed Member
Since I now live and work in PA, will PA's laws apply to me, or MD since the case will be in a MD court?

It is my understanding that PA allows more protections as far as garnishments are concerned and of course I am wondering if these will apply to me.

Thank in advance!
Assuming that the employer is a PA employer and does not make your payroll out of Maryland it will be Pennsylvania rules that will apply. The lender, even if it wins a judgment in MD, will have to domesticate that judgment in PA and enforce it using PA's rules for judgments. Wage garnishment is not permitted for most private debts in PA (landlord rent claims being a notable exception to that).
 

Zigner

Senior Member, Non-Attorney
Assuming that the employer is a PA employer and does not make your payroll out of Maryland it will be Pennsylvania rules that will apply. The lender, even if it wins a judgment in MD, will have to domesticate that judgment in PA and enforce it using PA's rules for judgments. Wage garnishment is not permitted for most private debts in PA (landlord rent claims being a notable exception to that).
The laws of the state in which the employee performs work (i.e., is employed in) are what determines the rules for garnishment.
 

Taxing Matters

Overtaxed Member
The laws of the state in which the employee performs work (i.e., is employed in) are what determines the rules for garnishment.
I disagree. In some circumstances the wages of an employee may be garnished by serving a garnishment order on the employer’s out-of-state office, e.g. headquarters or payroll processing office and the laws of the state where the garnishment was served would then apply. Maryland applies a rule that where the following two conditions are met the wages of an out-of-state employee may be garnished by serving the garnishment order in Maryland: (1) the case giving rise to that judgment against the employee was litigated in Maryland and the judgment entered in a court of Maryland and (2) the employer upon which the garnishment order is served is subject to the jurisdiction of Maryland courts, i.e. located in Maryland or has sufficient contacts in that state to be subject to jurisdiction there.

That rule comes about from a recent Maryland Court of Appeals case, in which the court states:

In conclusion, MCT could enforce the money judgments against Mr. Mensah through garnishments of Mr. Mensah's wages earned in Texas through the exercise of the original and ancillary jurisdiction of the district court that entered the judgments and because of BASF's business contacts in the State.​

Mensah v. MCT Fed. Credit Union, 446 Md. 525, 542, 132 A.3d 332, 342 (2016). In that case, MCT had obtained a judgment against Mensah in Maryland District Court. It then obtained a writ of garnishment and served it on Mensah’s employer, BASF. At the time the garnishment was served, Mensah was a resident of Texas and worked for BASF in Texas. Mensah objected to the garnishment order saying that Texas law (much like Pennsylvania) bars wage garnishments for most private debts and that Maryland courts lacked the power to attach those wages. The court disagreed with Mensah and sided with the creditor in this instance, creating the rule I mentioned above.

Thus, if the OP is indeed sued in Maryland and the creditor obtains a judgment there, if his employer is subject to jurisdiction in Maryland by, say, having an office there, the judgment creditor could indeed garnish the OP’s wages in Maryland using Maryland’s wage garnishment rules, notwithstanding that Pennsylvania would not permit that same garnishment. The Mensah case is just over 2 years old so it is very recent and has not been overturned.

Nor is Maryland unique in having this kind of rule. An attorney who practices in this area wrote an article for the site National Law Review which summarizes the rules in general for this sort of thing, but of course in any such case the law needs to be carefully researched as the states vary in the extent to which they follow the general principle mentioned in that article. You can find that article here:
https://www.natlawreview.com/article/compliance-rules-out-state-garnishments
 
Last edited:

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top