I stand corrected, but what a stupid law. If I were locked out I would wait till about 1 in the morning and call to request the key. If they have to give the key to the tenant without collecting any money then what is the purpose? A confrantation? I would simply ask for the key refuse to speak any more and walk away.
What makes you think the landlord would open the door at 1:00 AM The inconvenience and aggravation to the tenant may be worth the effort.
I personally would not be interested in what the tenant would say, but he would hear what I have to say.
But the reality is that your tenants should not know where you live. I suppose the LL could have the keys dropped off at his attorneys office.
Well, I have to edit this post. It appears the keys have to be given to the tenant within 2 hours of the request so, all the landlord can do is delay.
This law may be more of a pain in the rear for both tenant and LL.