• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

A friend in need...

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

Status
Not open for further replies.

SMinNJ

Member
What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? NJ

I am writing completely in knowledge of the board's hatred of third party posts, and with free admittance that I do not have all the facts of the case. However, a friend is hurting, and we acknowledge that he is truly too lazy to seek out answers on his own, so we'd like to be able to pass on advice.

The couple in question are members of our church. They have two children, ages 6 and 9. The wife has been diagnosed bipolar, and has been hospitalized for swallowing a bottle of pills. Recently, her psychiatrist retired and her new psychiatrist has decided that she suffers from PTSD, not bipolar disorder, and so she has stopped taking her medication. Each time previously that she has stopped her medication, her family life has suffered, and such is the case now.

The family has been in a mess for a long time. They have not made a mortgage payment since last September. For some reason no one understands, there are no foreclosure actions in place, but everyone understands it is a matter of time. He is a Catholic schoolteacher, she works in a real estate office in a clerical role.

They apparently fight regularly. After their arguments, she will go out and spend money frivolously, on herself. She has admitted publicly to this, and will spend $400 on a handbag, or money on clothes, all for herself.

Their home is a sty, frankly. There is a path from the front door to the other rooms, and that is the only clear space. Dad will not allow the children to have their friends in the house because of the disorder. When mom was in the hospital for the pills, the church ladies went over to clean and did 27 loads of laundry. The mess has re-established itself since that time.

Approximately two weeks ago, she had an argument with her husband, and she wanted to go out - not leave him, just go out. She had been screaming, crying, etc., and he told her that he didn't think that she should be driving. He took her keys, and went to her purse, removing her wallet so as to remove their debit card. She jumped on his back to stop him from doing this and beat on his back. She called the police, who came and made out a police report, stating such. The next day, she obtained a TRO on the basis of this incident and took the children out of the home.

He went to some sort of expedited hearing the next business day, and it was established that he could have a supervised visitation with his children on Saturday. This visitation did not happen because her lawyer was on vacation and unavailable to his lawyer. During that week, she crashed her car, causing an overnight hospital stay. She also called an ambulance twice, once for heart palpitations and a second time for pain in her knee.

Two days after going to the hospital for her knee, she went to the police and swore out a criminal complaint for assault against her husband, claiming that her knee was injured during the taking of her money. He went to court on his own, paid a bail, and was released.

During this time, she has sent the children to stay overnight with various church members, and most recently, her husband's parents. When one of the church members went to the family home to help clean, the church member asked whether she could have the kids call the husband. Mom said, "Well, if you want to use your own phone for that, go ahead." The woman did, the children spoke to dad. After the conversation was over, mom said, now get the f*** out of my house. If you're not going to stand on my side, get out." Last night, when the children were with the paternal grandparents, they asked her whether the kids could talk to dad on the phone, and her response was, "If you must." So they did.

The day after the assault charge, the children were brought to the church, with mom's permission, by a church member. Neither mom nor dad were present. Apparently, the tro includes the children, so dad stayed away. The church member took the children back to her home for mom to pick them up. The church member lives around the corner from the building. Someone called dad when the children left so that he could attend a men's planning committee meeting and a prayer meeting. Mom drove by the church with the kids, saw dad's car, and brought the kids back into the church, and demanded to enter the men's meeting. She saw her husband, hollered, "Get him the he** out of here!" and then proceeded to threaten my husband with charges and a restraining order, and screamed that she was done with the church and that her children were done with the church.

The pastor called the police after the incident. The officer had been flagged down by mom on his way to the call, so he had heard her side. He told her that she couldn't get dad in trouble with the restraining order when she went to places that he was, and that he was allowed to go to his church.

The children have reported, on their own, to various church members, that their mom is filing for bankruptcy so that they can keep the house, and that mom is filing things with the police so that they don't have to see dad. The daughter also reported that mom said that now that dad is not living there, they can have friends over. Daughter recently called one of her friends a "selfish bitch", which is not usual talk for a church family.

Their cell phones (their only phones) have been disconnected due to non-payment. They only had $108 in their joint account at the time she left, and he took $103 of it. She cancelled his car insurance. They clearly have no money, so it's all really a moot point.

They are both employed, as I said. She has not been going to work, been calling out, so much so that as of Sept. 1, her employer designated her to part-time status, so she lost her insurance.

Do you have any advice for the husband as to what he can do regarding this situation and his kids? I know that there are two sides to all stories, but as one of our elders said, he is really too lazy to actually hit his wife... he has seen warning signs for soooo long, and done nothing, he has been content not to pay his mortgage, because some financial advisor told him not to, but he hasn't been saving the money. His wife buys things, on their joint cards, and it doesn't occur to him to take them back to the store - he doesn't want to work, and I'm sure advice will fall on deaf ears, but I'd like to be able to advise him to soothe my heart.What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)?What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)?What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)?
 
Last edited:


Ohiogal

Queen Bee
So has he filed for divorce yet? has anyone called CPS about the living conditions at the home?
 

SMinNJ

Member
So has he filed for divorce yet? has anyone called CPS about the living conditions at the home?
No and no.

My instinct was that he needs to file for divorce, although the Christian faith would say that he could not do that. But my belief was that the longer that the children live under the TRO that limits his access to them, the worse it will be for him. As I said, he is a teacher, so for the summer months at least, he is the primary caregiver.

I want to call DYFS about the living conditions - I have seen them personally. Is a filthy house where the trash hasn't been removed in weeks bad enough for DYFS to do something?
 

Ohiogal

Queen Bee
No and no.

My instinct was that he needs to file for divorce, although the Christian faith would say that he could not do that. But my belief was that the longer that the children live under the TRO that limits his access to them, the worse it will be for him. As I said, he is a teacher, so for the summer months at least, he is the primary caregiver.

I want to call DYFS about the living conditions - I have seen them personally. Is a filthy house where the trash hasn't been removed in weeks bad enough for DYFS to do something?
It very well could be. Report uninhabitable conditions.
 

Isis1

Senior Member
i'm not excusing mom's behavior AT ATLL. but dad STILL had no business to withhold mom's purse, keys and debit card from her. if he doesn't want her to spend HIS money, then he shoul dhave a seperate account.

he definitely needs to file for divorce/custody/support immediately.

someone who really cares, needs to call CPS.

and this "trash" in the house didn't accumalate overnight, so dad is also responsible for allowing the mess to get that way.

if dad cares, dad needs to stop being lazy and get moving. right now.
 

LdiJ

Senior Member
CPS may just order them to clean up the house the first time, and then they will call on the church ladies to help them, and it will get cleaned up, CPS will sign off on it, and then it will be all messed up again.
 

wileybunch

Senior Member
Why do you suppose Dad has a reputation for being too lazy to do anything about this situation? Is he depressed or just not a good protector for his kids?
 

SMinNJ

Member
CPS may just order them to clean up the house the first time, and then they will call on the church ladies to help them, and it will get cleaned up, CPS will sign off on it, and then it will be all messed up again.
Honestly, most of the church ladies are done with her. After her tellng off one of the ladies, storming the church, after her daughter calls her own best friend a selfish b****, they are through. I spoke to one of the ladies who had in fact been asked to come over to help clean, and as we talked, she came to the conclusion that by cleaning the house for her, we are only facilitating her breakdown and her destruction of whatever is left of the marriage. Additionally, I received a phone call last night from another one of the women. She had gotten a call from mom, which ordered the women to not call her because she wanted nothing to do with us. She apparently singled out several families, specifically mine (because my husband asked her to calm down when she stormed the church on Wednesday night). She says that if any of us call her, she will go to the police and file a complaint against us.

So, while I think she'll call us to try to get help, even after her non-calling request, I don't think any of the ladies would help.
 

SMinNJ

Member
Why do you suppose Dad has a reputation for being too lazy to do anything about this situation? Is he depressed or just not a good protector for his kids?

I think there's a little of column A and a little of column B. As I said, he really is too lazy to do much of anything. I see him attempting to discipline his kids at church, but it never sticks, and I'm supposing that is because the ONLY time he disciplines his kids is at church. They (the kids) are too easily upset by the discipline (which is not corporal, and not screaming, just quiet explanation) for it to be normal in their lives. When his wife swallowed the pills, he didn't know exactly what medication she was on, who her psychiatrist was, or whether she was in any talk therapy in addition to the medication. She had been asking to be hospitalized for weeks, and he had taken her to the hospital several times, but the hospital refused to admit her because she was not a danger to herself or others. They told her that if she were cutting herself, or attempting suicide, they could admit her. So, she went home and tried cutting herself. Apparently, she didn't make it too serious, because they still wouldn't admit her. That's when she swallowed the pills. That worked, and got her in for two days. She had stopped taking all of her medication because she felt it was making her fat. I don't doubt that she was depressed, but we have seen her have a history of creating a drama when issues in her life get bad. I think that this restraining order/taking the kids drama is her way of avoiding her responsibility for things, because people always rally around them in time of crisis. This time, it backfired on her.

He, on the other hand, really just doesn't care enough about anyone to do anything. Not knowing his wife's doctor's and info about her therapy is negligent. He has never attempted to get a parttime job to supplement their income. He continues to buy convenience store coffee and to take the kids out for ice cream, etc. He knows nothing about bi-polar disorder, because as he said, "That's her thing." He is irresponsible, lazy, and apathetic. Why, I can't say for sure. His parents are selfish people who refused to assist him to do anything as a youth, and never encouraged him to do things on his own. They told him he was too stupid to go to college. When he did, and became a teacher, they told him he should have done something like become a doctor or a lawyer, and that teaching was for those who can't. While I can appreciate this as a reason, my thought on it was, "Get over yourself!" The man is 35, with a wife and a two children, and it really is time for him to grow up. Even though I am committed to helping him gain access to his children, I don't hold him innocent at all, and as lazy as he is, I think he makes a far better parent than she does - not because of her disorder, but because of her vindictiveness and the fact that she has allowed her children to witness all of these things, and has clearly been talking to them about it, in a negative fashion. These children are heartbroken, and she is really doing nothing to alleviate their suffering. Instead, she has been dragging them around or dropping them off to church families for overnights while she actively works to destroy their lives. Their dad sits back, and their mom wreaks havoc. Neither is innocent.
 

LdiJ

Senior Member
I think there's a little of column A and a little of column B. As I said, he really is too lazy to do much of anything. I see him attempting to discipline his kids at church, but it never sticks, and I'm supposing that is because the ONLY time he disciplines his kids is at church. They (the kids) are too easily upset by the discipline (which is not corporal, and not screaming, just quiet explanation) for it to be normal in their lives. When his wife swallowed the pills, he didn't know exactly what medication she was on, who her psychiatrist was, or whether she was in any talk therapy in addition to the medication. She had been asking to be hospitalized for weeks, and he had taken her to the hospital several times, but the hospital refused to admit her because she was not a danger to herself or others. They told her that if she were cutting herself, or attempting suicide, they could admit her. So, she went home and tried cutting herself. Apparently, she didn't make it too serious, because they still wouldn't admit her. That's when she swallowed the pills. That worked, and got her in for two days. She had stopped taking all of her medication because she felt it was making her fat. I don't doubt that she was depressed, but we have seen her have a history of creating a drama when issues in her life get bad. I think that this restraining order/taking the kids drama is her way of avoiding her responsibility for things, because people always rally around them in time of crisis. This time, it backfired on her.

He, on the other hand, really just doesn't care enough about anyone to do anything. Not knowing his wife's doctor's and info about her therapy is negligent. He has never attempted to get a parttime job to supplement their income. He continues to buy convenience store coffee and to take the kids out for ice cream, etc. He knows nothing about bi-polar disorder, because as he said, "That's her thing." He is irresponsible, lazy, and apathetic. Why, I can't say for sure. His parents are selfish people who refused to assist him to do anything as a youth, and never encouraged him to do things on his own. They told him he was too stupid to go to college. When he did, and became a teacher, they told him he should have done something like become a doctor or a lawyer, and that teaching was for those who can't. While I can appreciate this as a reason, my thought on it was, "Get over yourself!" The man is 35, with a wife and a two children, and it really is time for him to grow up. Even though I am committed to helping him gain access to his children, I don't hold him innocent at all, and as lazy as he is, I think he makes a far better parent than she does - not because of her disorder, but because of her vindictiveness and the fact that she has allowed her children to witness all of these things, and has clearly been talking to them about it, in a negative fashion. These children are heartbroken, and she is really doing nothing to alleviate their suffering. Instead, she has been dragging them around or dropping them off to church families for overnights while she actively works to destroy their lives. Their dad sits back, and their mom wreaks havoc. Neither is innocent.
If you really want to help him, then I think that the first step is to encourage him to get a job...unless I misunderstood you and you were talking about a second job rather than a primary job.

He needs to really get HIS act in order so that he is in a strong position for at least shared parenting.
 

stealth2

Under the Radar Member
My instinct was that he needs to file for divorce, although the Christian faith would say that he could not do that.
Not to get into a theological debate, but please don't propogate such myths. Perhaps your particular flavor of Christianity is 100% against divorce, ever, but not all are. There are some that allow for divorce under certain circumstances, and will actually even provide a Church-sanctioned divorce (not an annulment, an actual ecclesiastical divorce) in those cases.

Honestly, most of the church ladies are done with her. After her tellng off one of the ladies, storming the church, after her daughter calls her own best friend a selfish b****, they are through. I spoke to one of the ladies who had in fact been asked to come over to help clean, and as we talked, she came to the conclusion that by cleaning the house for her, we are only facilitating her breakdown and her destruction of whatever is left of the marriage. Additionally, I received a phone call last night from another one of the women. She had gotten a call from mom, which ordered the women to not call her because she wanted nothing to do with us. She apparently singled out several families, specifically mine (because my husband asked her to calm down when she stormed the church on Wednesday night). She says that if any of us call her, she will go to the police and file a complaint against us.

So, while I think she'll call us to try to get help, even after her non-calling request, I don't think any of the ladies would help.
Frankly, from your other posts in this thread, it certainly sounds as though both of these parents need some serious mental health help. Especially Mom, but at least she's been trying to get some, regardless of how dramatically. And, really.... it comes off as the "church ladies" sort of enjoy the drama and the ability to gossip about it. Which isn't all too..... Christian. Nor is the likelihood of refusing help to one who asks. IMO, of course.
 

CourtClerk

Senior Member
Not to get into a theological debate, but please don't propogate such myths. Perhaps your particular flavor of Christianity is 100% against divorce, ever, but not all are. There are some that allow for divorce under certain circumstances, and will actually even provide a Church-sanctioned divorce (not an annulment, an actual ecclesiastical divorce) in those cases.
I agree, because there are instances IN THE BIBLE where people were divorced.


Frankly, from your other posts in this thread, it certainly sounds as though both of these parents need some serious mental health help. Especially Mom, but at least she's been trying to get some, regardless of how dramatically. And, really.... it comes off as the "church ladies" sort of enjoy the drama and the ability to gossip about it. Which isn't all too..... Christian. Nor is the likelihood of refusing help to one who asks. IMO, of course.
^5
 

SMinNJ

Member
Not to get into a theological debate, but please don't propogate such myths. Perhaps your particular flavor of Christianity is 100% against divorce, ever, but not all are. There are some that allow for divorce under certain circumstances, and will actually even provide a Church-sanctioned divorce (not an annulment, an actual ecclesiastical divorce) in those cases.
.
The Bible permits divorce in two circumstances - adultery and if an unbelieving spouse decides to leave. Therefore, unless he can prove one of those two things, he should not file for divorce. The Bible calls for Christians not to go to a secular court to settle their differences, but rather to deal with it inside the faith. It also provides a method for dealing with such difficulties. She has not attempted to use those methods and instead went to a secular court. We are of a garden variety, Bible-believing, evangelic faith. Also, not wanting to get into a theological debate, just providing clarification.

Frankly, from your other posts in this thread, it certainly sounds as though both of these parents need some serious mental health help. Especially Mom, but at least she's been trying to get some, regardless of how dramatically. And, really.... it comes off as the "church ladies" sort of enjoy the drama and the ability to gossip about it. Which isn't all too..... Christian. Nor is the likelihood of refusing help to one who asks. IMO, of course.
They both do need serious mental health help. No question. Mom has not actually been trying to get some - each time she gets help, she argues against it and refuses to do what she is asked to do for any length of time. What she enjoys is the attention.

I'm sorry if anything I said gave the impression that the church ladies are gossiping. Perhaps this is a stereotype, but it does not fit our situation. We have discussed the situation in an attempt to best help mom, dad, and the children. We are heartbroken about the situation, and want the best outcome, so we have discussed the situation in terms of scripture and what loving this family best looks like. Gossiping is talking that involves no action - just enjoying the tragedy of others for entertainment.

Additionally, I would argue that helping someone do something when it will ultimately hurt them is not Christian. If the church women continually go to her house to clean it, we are not teaching her how to be responsible. If we continually watch her children while she goes to the police to file charges against her husband, we are encouraging her to do this rather than to deal with things in a scriptural manner. We would be doing these things for her as a member of the church, as a believer in our faith, as a sister in Christ, and if we continue to do things that will encourage her to live in a manner that goes against our beliefs, we are ourselves joining her in the sin.

I apologize for using the generic Christian term in describing us - we are born-again Christians and Christian is the term we use, but I recognize that other faiths would lump themselves into that category as well. We do not condone divorce, except in the two instances previously mentioned. We do not condone taking children away from their parents. We believe that you should train your children up in the way that they should go, and what we have seen in this situation is this mother doing the exact opposite of what her own faith would have her do. And before it's brought up, we would, of course, assist a non-believer - we don't withhold help because a non-believer doesn't share the same faith. But once someone professes faith and accepts God's grace, it is part of the church responsibility to help the weaker brother - and that doesn't involve assisting them to commit sinful acts.

None of this is intended to be a slight on anyone of any faith who is divorced, has filed a restraining order, etc. I like all of you all, and in general, I don't think you are exceptionally sinful beings :).

I sincerely hope this is taken in the positive spirit it was intended.
 

majomom1

Senior Member
I get real tired of people saying they cannot divorce because of religion.

But you know what? The bible also states the role for men and women. It gives work ethic and responsibility for each. I find it ironic that some "fear" filing divorce yet have no problem NOT fulfilling all the other areas of life... according to the Bible.

Dad isn't following the path of a Christian man in his day to day living, so why is filing for divorce such a big deal. The other option is to work harder, pay the creditors, seek counseling and do whatever it takes to repair the family.

He has two choices. He can give up and quit or he can be a true Christian, get off his butt and DO SOMETHING!
 

CJane

Senior Member
So Dad is too lazy (read, uninvolved in reality) to

1) Clean his filthy house
2) Pay his bills
3) Know what medication his wife is on
4) Know who his wife's mental health professional is
5) See an attorney
6) Hire an attorney to fight an assault charge

BUT he's not too lazy to forcibly keep his wife in the home by stealing her keys and her money.

Of course SHE is the bad guy in the situation because SHE is the unChristian one. Never mind that Dad is not even behaving as an ADULT let alone a 'believer'.

Whatever. They should get as far away from each other as possible and stay that way. The church should BUTT OUT of Mom's life UNLESS SHE ASKS FOR HELP and the kids should be in serious counseling OUTSIDE CHURCH and be exchanged in a public location.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top