Mom got Dad's approval and she did offer other time.
Where did it say that she got Dad's approval? I went back through the entire thread and there's nothing to support that. In fact, it is clear that Mom scheduled something that conflicts with Dad's time OVER HIS OBJECTIONS.
It is not HER fault and it is sad that Dad is being a PIA.
No, it's not her fault that Dad is a PIA. It IS, however, her fault that she scheduled something on Dad's time. No parent has the right to unilaterally infringe on the other parent's parenting time.
The kid loses here, not mom.
The kid certainly loses - but Mom's the one who scheduled the activity without permission. AND Mom refuses to give Dad double time in order to allow the child to participate.
The message is: "My time is important and I'm not giving it up, but you should have to give up your time". That's completely unfair.
In all the posts I have seen from both Stealth and Misto, neither of you would not stand for this. You would offer double, or even triple time... and then rip the other parent in court.
"Neither of you would not stand for this"???
I've made my position clear. It is legally correct and, in my opinion, morally right.
Each parent is legally entitled to their time without interference from the other parent. Mom was wrong to schedule something on Dad's time without permission. It would be equally wrong if Dad had done that.
Mom is free to go to court to try to get an order for the child to participate, but there's no guarantee the judge will do it. The courts generally prefer not to get involved in simple parenting decisions like this - and expect each parent to have their own time without hindrance. In fact, there's an outside chance that the judge will lash out at Mom for infringing on Dad's parenting time.
If the tournament is important to the child (not to Mom), then Mom may need to make a sacrifice in order for the child to participate. I've certainly given up plenty of parenting time (and money) in order for my child to do things that she wanted to do when it was more convenient for her to be with her mother (or mother-daughter events at school, for example). If Mom is unwilling to give up a little extra of her time (not just a 1:1 swap which doesn't involve sacrifice), then I guess she doesn't care any more for the kids' activities then Dad does.
Again, Dad is a PIA. But he's allowed to exercise his parenting time without interference and Mom has no right to DEMAND that he give up some of his time.