• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Ethnic group asked to move seat location during exam

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Invictus31

Junior Member
What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? Florida

This past Sunday was our Genetics Final at my University. The lecture hall was packed due to there being 5 additional foreign language classes taking their exam as well.

We sat where ever there was space. I sat alongside my friend whom is the same ethnicity as me. In my particular row, a group up us of ethnic background were sitting together (about 10-12 of mixed ethnic races), the majority being my ethnicity. The professor comes up to my my row and asks all of us to get up. Then she states out loud verbatim in front of the entire class, "all of you have been suspected of suspicious activity in the past". I have never sat next to either of the people around my for any previous exam, nor has any individual ever been accused or confronted of cheating or anything of the sort in the past. The professor asks all of us to get up and the T.A.'s proceed to individually assign us to different locations around the hall.

She then proceeds to the other end of the hall and starts moving members of the same ethnicity as myself where ever there were 2 or more of us seated together. No other race was asked to get up and relocate from their seats no matter how many of them were seated in a row. She was also quoted as saying, "time to break up the pods" during her course of action. I would estimate that 20-25 members of a single ethnicity were made to stand up from their seats and relocate. Amongst this group, 2 or 3 were of a different ethnicity and asked to move because they were seated amongst my row of 10-12 students who was told to get up.

Again, not a single person moved has ever been accused of suspected of cheating or anything of the source in the past.

Two of us attempted to contact the Dean of the Department but were told by her assistant we must make an appointment through e-mail which we have done so today.

Please advise me as to what legal action can be taken. All of us were publicly humiliated and slandered against in front of a 300 student lecture hall of our peers right before the final exam for the course.
 


Zigner

Senior Member, Non-Attorney
What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? Florida

This past Sunday was our Genetics Final at my University. The lecture hall was packed due to there being 5 additional foreign language classes taking their exam as well.

We sat where ever there was space. I sat alongside my friend whom is the same ethnicity as me. In my particular row, a group up us of ethnic background were sitting together (about 10-12 of mixed ethnic races), the majority being my ethnicity. The professor comes up to my my row and asks all of us to get up. Then she states out loud verbatim in front of the entire class, "all of you have been suspected of suspicious activity in the past". I have never sat next to either of the people around my for any previous exam, nor has any individual ever been accused or confronted of cheating or anything of the sort in the past. The professor asks all of us to get up and the T.A.'s proceed to individually assign us to different locations around the hall.

She then proceeds to the other end of the hall and starts moving members of the same ethnicity as myself where ever there were 2 or more of us seated together. No other race was asked to get up and relocate from their seats no matter how many of them were seated in a row. She was also quoted as saying, "time to break up the pods" during her course of action. I would estimate that 20-25 members of a single ethnicity were made to stand up from their seats and relocate. Amongst this group, 2 or 3 were of a different ethnicity and asked to move because they were seated amongst my row of 10-12 students who was told to get up.

Again, not a single person moved has ever been accused of suspected of cheating or anything of the source in the past.

Two of us attempted to contact the Dean of the Department but were told by her assistant we must make an appointment through e-mail which we have done so today.

Please advise me as to what legal action can be taken. All of us were publicly humiliated and slandered against in front of a 300 student lecture hall of our peers right before the final exam for the course.
You could get thicker skin :rolleyes:
 

Mass_Shyster

Senior Member
Two of us attempted to contact the Dean of the Department but were told by her assistant we must make an appointment through e-mail which we have done so today.

Please advise me as to what legal action can be taken.
You should wait and see what happens with the Dean of the Department. In general, you must exhaust all available remedies before resorting to the courts. If you don't like the response from the Dean, go back with all of the students who feel they were singled out due solely to their race. You stated that there 20 to 25. If 20 to 25 students show up at the Dean's office, it will make more of an impression than two.

If, after 25 of you show up and still get no satisfaction, contact an attorney to see if he or she feels anything more can be done.
 

CdwJava

Senior Member
Understand that an attorney will want to be paid. Even if the professor acted in a purely, biased, and racially prejudice manner, it may not give rise to a lawsuit that has any hope of an award sufficient to attract an attorney to take the case on a contingency fee basis. The embarrassment may be real, but the damages are likely nil. As such, you'd have to pay the attorney out of pocket in the hopes that a jury might decide you deserve money for pain and suffering that will exceed the many thousands you will have to pay an attorney.

Start with the dean and see what can be done there. It may be a misunderstanding, it may be an ignorant professor, or the man may just have some serious prejudices. But, aside from the possible embarrassment I don't see that you have any significant monetary claims.

The reality is that justice is most often about money. You may well have been wronged, but it may not be sufficient to result in any award.
 

swalsh411

Senior Member
Back up a second. What law does the OP think has been broken here? Professors can make students in their class change seats. They are in charge.

The OP can't know for sure that there haven't been cheating allegations made against the people he was sitting with. How could he possibly know that?

The OP is welcome to complain to the administration but this isn't even close to a legal issue.

edit: Oh and the ethnicities are irrelevant and the OP is either paranoid or race baiting.
 
Last edited:

antrc170

Member
I agree with swalsh on this one. Even though the professor may be biased, what damage other than embarassment can the OP show? The OP along with the others were still allowed to take the test just in different seating arrangement. Although the OP claims that no one was ever suspected of cheating the professor did announce that there were suspicions of such and that was the reason for the move.
 

Zigner

Senior Member, Non-Attorney
Although the OP claims that no one was ever suspected of cheating the professor did announce that there were suspicions of such and that was the reason for the move.
No. The Prof said: "all of you have been suspected of suspicious activity in the past"
 

dmcc10880

Member
If this is an isolate incident and the professor has not engaged in any ethnically biased actions in the past, I have to agree with Zigner. Toughen up, you'll be in the real world soon.
 

antrc170

Member
No. The Prof said: "all of you have been suspected of suspicious activity in the past"
...and that was the reason for the move. Although not specifically stated it is the inferred reason as it accompanied the movement of students.
 

Ozark_Sophist

Senior Member
Followup with the university. If you don't get satisfaction, file a complaint with the Office of Civil Rights for the US Department of Education. Each student should file his or her complaint separately to increase the likelihood the OCR will investigate.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top