To recap, state is Texas, and my neighbor's fencing contractor trespassed onto my property and cut down my hedge along the party fence. I have had trouble identifying the name of the fencing contractor but believe I have it now. I emailed the fencing contractor and my neghbor and they each offered about $100 in compensation. I obtained two estimates from landscapers, one for $1700 and one for $2700. I then submitted a formal demand letter to the neighbor and the fencing contractor attaching the two estimates. At this point, they both withdraw their offers and said they would pay nothing. I am now in process of filing my claim in small claims court.
Questions:
(A) Is two estimates enough? I've tried to get more estimates but some landscapers have turned me down because the job is too small, and others came to visit and then never submitted an estimate. It's time-consuming trying to get more than the two estimates I already have.
(B) I briefed the two landscapers who gave me estimates that I wanted mature plants to replace my 10-year old hedge that had been cut down. They can't find plants of the same species and height of those that were cut down. They could get me baby plants in those species or different species that are bigger but still not as big as those I lost. Would the judge accept that it is reaonable to install plants that are available in my area and give maximum coverage of the party fence?
While two estimates can be enough, because there is a thousand dollar difference between the two estimates you have, I think you should get a third estimate. One thousand dollars is a significant difference.
The fact that the species of plant that was cut down by the contractor is no longer available can be important to note. The fact that these were mature plants is also important.
I suggest you also have before and after photos.
And I suggest you have information about the plants that were removed and have replacement costs for more than a single type of plant. You want the judge to know you are not trying to replace, for example, dandelions with roses.
If you haven't asked the homeowner and the contractor for their insurance information yet, you should.
Thank you for the update. Good luck.