• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Tenant possible Pedo. My liability?

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

Oregon

We bought a property in another country, and decided to spend a year there, while renting out our very large home.
We rented 4 of the 5 bedrooms to a contracting crew here building a business. The 5th ( Our master suite) we rented to a fairly well known co-worker of mine. The house was fully furnished. He was to somewhat 'manage' the property-- water the landscaping, plants, and make sure lights got turned off, keep an eye on maintenance, etc. In exchange, he got a great deal on rent, and paid no utilities. We had a cleaning person in every two weeks, to keep on top of floors, and bathrooms.
We moved our personal items into the mother in law apartment attached to our garage.
We came back every 90 days. On multiple occasions , on the weekends, we noticed several juvenile boys ( 10-14) entering and exiting the home. The contracting crew was only there Monday - Thursday, going home on the weekends. The front door and all bedroom doors are passcode protected. From the adjacent apartment, it appeared the 'caretaker' was subletting the rooms on the weekends. There were lights on, in what should be empty rooms, showers being taken in the hall bathroom, while the contractors were gone for the weekend, etc. We approached him, and he denied subletting. Said he had a friend stay for a few days to watch his cat. We hadn't known he had a cat. He then moved a man into his own room, but said he was just 'staying' there for a day or two, but that he was 'cool'- he even had an apartment in our town, and a pregnant girlfriend.
A few months in, he texted asking to adopt another cat, because his was about to die. We declined, and told him we had not known he had a cat until after he had mentioned it when we asked him about the other guy, and we did NOT want pets to begin with. He had an anxiety attack when we told him that. Like, the call 911 kind.
We agreed to let him keep the cat in his room only because there were other tenants, and the cleaning lady said she was continuously picking up 'cat piles'. FOr some reason, we must've thought we needed him because we were so far away. Writing this, Im thinking- why the hell didnt we give him notice right then?!

We were notified by neighbors that the tenant always had young men in and out of the house. 12-16 year olds. They were very concerned for the welfare of these boys, as our tenant is a mid 30's, gay male. We were aware of the boys, but not what happens once they entered the house. The contracting crew never said anything when asked, nor said they saw anything.
After 14 months (a two month extension) the contractors finished up and moved out of our furnished home. The other tenant did not. He messaged us asking if he could rent the rooms- but we already knew we did not want him in our home any longer. We let him know we would be coming home, and that we would be reoccupying our home. My husband and son went back immediately, rented out the apartment attached to the garage (so he could not ask to move into it), moved back into the house, and then occupied the private back room, because our 'tenant' was still in the master suite.
My husband noticed, on multiple occasions, strange people coming and going.
I arrived home a month later. One afternoon, we were standing in a downstairs room when we could hear a baby crying upstairs. Our tenant was at work. I knocked on the door, and called his name. No answer. The baby quieted, and I went back downstairs not knowing what to do. About 15 minutes later, 2 people with a car seat come out of the tenants room and head downstairs and out the door. Gone before I could ask any questions. It was the same man the tenant had said was only staying a few days.
I served him written notice of 30 days. I told him we were going to be selling. We changed the passcodes to all but his door, and ave him only the front door code. He begged to move into the private back room. He said he couldn't get a place with 2 cats (yep! he got one anyway). He didn't have the money to move. He has terrible anxiety and needs at least 4 months to find a place. Etc, etc. I told him maybe we could go 60 days, but no longer.

Meanwhile, We had stayed crammed into the private back room with our nine year old son, rather than having our child go back upstairs to his room next to the master, because we do not trust his interest in children. The private back room is very quiet.
But this week, my husband, son, and I moved into two of the four, large upstairs rooms. The tenant is still occupying the master suite (its 300 sq ft w/attached large bathroom).
But then, this morning, after our tenant left for work ,I went to go downstairs into my kitchen for coffee (in my underwear), and I pass the very slightly open door to the master suite. I see a maaaaaybe 13 year old boy, getting out of bed and pulling his pants on. I scramble back to my room to get dressed, and come immediately back out as the kid slams the front door and takes off down the road.
I message the tenant asking who the kid is. He claims its one of the students that are helping him with a fundraiser project, it got late last night so he just stayed over. I again reminded him, that only he has only rented ONE room, and with us home now, we did not want people in our home without him there. He said no problem. Again.
My question is- If something is happening to these young boys, are we liable? Can their parents sue us?
and how can we get him out if he wont leave?? We never had a rental agreement with him. Only the contractors had a lease.
I do not have ANY paperwork for this 'renter', aside from the 30 days, which he is now past, with no indication of any intention of moving. He pays his rent via GooglePay and now just avoids us by creeping up and down the stairs and jetting outside so we cant talk to him.

Aside from telling us how naive, stupid, idiotic we are- does any one have any advice/experience with this?

__________________
 


FarmerJ

Senior Member
You are not responsible for ANY illegal actions of this tenant, If you have given what your state defines to be a proper written notice to this tenant telling the tenant to get out and the tenant has not then its time to use the court system and evict him thru the courts.
 

HRZ

Senior Member
Make double sure your insurance is full replacement value and covers rental operations ...this could get worse quickly!

Tenants have piles of rights in NY...and a few wrong words about his sexual orientation is likely to get you in boiling oil .

I suggest you follow the eviction steps in NY to a T...starting tomorrow , and if you cannot figure them out, hire a lawyer skilled at evictions sometime this week.

I would have the place full of recording security cameras PRONTO...but not aimed into rooms or places where one would expect privacy ...you want to know everyone who comes and goes ....and no comments about young boys !!!

MY guess is no matter what time you give him he will need more...don't go down that road.

IT might work to offer a big wad of cash for keys/written surrender of the unit ..literally cash as he permanently leaves ...make it big enough to make him drool ..you may only get one chance....and don't let him back in for anything ..not even to use a bathroom ....and his stuff is out in a uhaul or whatever it takes.

You might not technically be liable for his conduct or his choice of guests....but if something gets out of hand...you will be roasted in public....you know pretty well things are improper!!

DO not make threats of reporting him to law enforcement unless he does X,Y, or Z....I don't know where the line is as to blackmail/extortion and neither do you
...leave anything of that sort to your lawyer who hopefully knows where the line in the sand may be.
 

xylene

Senior Member
It sounds like you just need to pony up and hire a lawyer.

You keep getting played by a manipulator.

You think this guy is a pedo, but somehow you are babysitting his anxiety?

Lastly, and bluntly, something is amiss in your story. I can't quite put my finger on it but you are either lying to us, or lying to yourselves. Something is off.
 

adjusterjack

Senior Member
Aside from telling us how naive, stupid, idiotic we are- does any one have any advice/experience with this?
Aside from those character traits you are obviously not capable of effectively being landlords and should quit as soon as possible and live in your house tenant free, or sell the house and get into a smaller place that fits you.

Meantime, get yourself a lawyer to file the eviction through the courts. You've already blown it by letting this slide as long as you have, especially now that it's beyond the 30 day notice.
 
It sounds like you just need to pony up and hire a lawyer.

You keep getting played by a manipulator.

You think this guy is a pedo, but somehow you are babysitting his anxiety?

Lastly, and bluntly, something is amiss in your story. I can't quite put my finger on it but you are either lying to us, or lying to yourselves. Something is off.

No- no lies unfortunately. However, as mentioned I do work with him- ish. We don't see each other at work, but have the same job for the same company. I suspect I've been nice-er to him than I should be, because we have worked together for almost ten years and I hate uncomfortable situations/conflict.. . and I trusted him not to screw us over. I hate feeling my trust has been violated, and I feel stupid for not protecting myself.
 

Just Blue

Senior Member
No- no lies unfortunately. However, as mentioned I do work with him- ish. We don't see each other at work, but have the same job for the same company. I suspect I've been nice-er to him than I should be, because we have worked together for almost ten years and I hate uncomfortable situations/conflict.. . and I trusted him not to screw us over. I hate feeling my trust has been violated, and I feel stupid for not protecting myself.
I think you are rather disgusting for not reporting suspected child molestation. And not only that you have your 9 year old son around this guy. Incredible.
 

HRZ

Senior Member
What you think may be going on may be darn hard to prove ....you have made major blunders already , don't make it worse by assuming things that get into libel/slander or by making threats that cross into extortion...

.you can make a report to law enforcement ..just stick to facts ...

Given you are unable to handle difficult situations ..you might be darn smarter to engage legal counsel to advocate and do things. ..pronto

Are you in some sort of academic employment ?
 
Aside from those character traits you are obviously not capable of effectively being landlords and should quit as soon as possible and live in your house tenant free, or sell the house and get into a smaller place that fits you.

Meantime, get yourself a lawyer to file the eviction through the courts. You've already blown it by letting this slide as long as you have, especially now that it's beyond the 30 day notice.
Thanks for the advice!
I imagine that made you feel really powerful and smart. I'm happy I could provide that for you. Sounds like you don't get a lot of opportunity for it, based on your displayed character traits.
Also, its your kind of people that enticed us to move from the US to begin with.
 
I do not have any hard evidence that anything is happening with these boys.
However, I am just as concerned as you are, without calling you disgusting.
Perhaps you haven't noticed that Landlords have few rights and are open to all sorts of litigation- thus, the visit to this site, asking for advice from people who have possibly experienced this.
I'm just choosing not to lose my house to this guy for making libel and slanderous accusations with no proof.
 

Just Blue

Senior Member
I do not have any hard evidence that anything is happening with these boys.
However, I am just as concerned as you are, without calling you disgusting.
Perhaps you haven't noticed that Landlords have few rights and are open to all sorts of litigation- thus, the visit to this site, asking for advice from people who have possibly experienced this.
I'm just choosing not to lose my house to this guy for making libel and slanderous accusations with no proof.
You chose the name of your thread.

If you suspect your tenant of having little boys, (Yes. LITTLE BOYS! 10-12 year old children are not "young men") over for sex, you go to the police and tell them what you observed and direct them to the neighbor who you state also saw random kids over there. What you don't do is continue to allow the guy to live at your house and bring your 9 year old to live with the guy as well. Even a goldfish has more sense with their young.
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top