My brother from Taiwan can get green card- together with his family

[ihot]

Since he has no intention of living with his family in the US, one must wonder if there is a qualifying family relationship between him and the rest of the family in Taiwan.

I am surprised that you have not heard of families who are willing to sacrifice for the good of their family members - allowing each members to choose for themselves to immigrate to USA, even if that means splitting up their families.
Kind Regards.

 

[ihot]

"One must wonder" about a lot of things ihot posted.

I think ihot will be best served by finding a "replacement" immigration attorney in his area, one who understands the law.

Perhaps you don't understand what my lawyer is saying. He knows immigation law. But he does not know of any cases where green cards were taken away from immigrants because their dad decided to give up his green card. In other words - immigration law is not enforced. You must have seen "non enforcement" all the time if you practice immigration law.

So how often have any of you "experienced immigration lawyers", seen green cards were taken away from immigrants because their dad decided to give up his green card?
That's the bottom line. Everything else is 'theory".

 

[quincy]

Well, ihot, you seem to have enough immigration attorneys around to advise you (even if only in free 1/2 hour increments) without the need for anyone here to assist. I suggest you speak with them to get it all figured out.

Good luck to you and your family.

 

[ihot]

Well, ihot, you seem to have enough immigration attorneys around to advise you (even if only in free 1/2 hour increments) without the need for anyone here to assist. I suggest you speak with them to get it all figured out.


Good luck to you and your family.

I think you are forgetting that your answers will be a resource to immigrants around the world with similar questions. This is not just about me.

I love the sound of silence!! I see that no "senior members" has challenged my last questions e.g. can you quote cases where green cards were lost by children of a parent gave up his green card? If no one can, then I guess you are all in agreement with one of my lawyers - he is right in spite of all the "paper tiger fraud" words thrown around in this thread.

I would like to hear all those who yelled "fraud" at me, what is their "expert opinion" of my other questions:
- Is pledging allegiance to the USA flag and flags of other countries considered "fraud" in US immigration law?
- "Amnesty" to illegals who committed fraud for years - is that fraud?

Will I hear Silence?
Thanks.

 

[Proserpina]

I think you are forgetting that your answers will be a resource to all immigrants around the world with similar questions. This is not just about me.

I love the sound of silence!! I see that no "senior members" has challenged my last questions e.g. can you quote cases where green cards were lost by children of a parent gave up his green card? If no one can, then I guess you are all in agreement with one of my lawyers - he is right in spite of all the "paper tiger fraud" words thrown around in this thread.

I would like to hear all those who yelled "fraud" at me, what is their "expert opinion" of my other questions:
So is pledging allegiance to the USA flag and flags of other countries considered "fraud" in US immigration law?
"Amnesty to illegals who committed fraud for years" - is that fraud?

Do I hear Silence?
Thanks.

Congratulations. This is the most useless post you've made so far.

Given that this is actually NONE of your legal business, you're lucky you even got responses.

You're welcome.

 

[quincy]

I think you are forgetting that your answers will be a resource to all immigrants around the world with similar questions. This is not just about me.

I love the sound of silence!! I see that no "senior members" has challenged my last questions e.g. can you quote cases where green cards were lost by children of a parent gave up his green card? If no one can, then I guess you are all in agreement with one of my lawyers - he is right in spite of all the "paper tiger fraud" words thrown around in this thread.

I would like to hear all those who yelled "fraud" at me, what is their "expert opinion" of my other questions:
So is pledging allegiance to the USA flag and flags of other countries considered "fraud" in US immigration law?
"Amnesty to illegals who committed fraud for years" - is that fraud?

Do I hear Silence?
Thanks.

No immigrant anywhere in the world should ever RELY on any free legal advice forum for advice on his/her own specific immigration legal needs.

Read the terms of service that you agreed to when you registered on this site.

No legal advice forum, regardless of whether the responder to a question on the forum is an attorney or not (and most of the members on this site are not attorneys), can provide any visitor with what an attorney in their own area can provide in the way of personal service. A review of ALL facts is necessary, and that personal review of all facts cannot be done in a forum setting.

All immigrants with immigration law questions, in other words, should seek out personal advice and direction from an immigration attorney in their area.

In your case, ihot, you claim to have several immigration attorneys already within easy reach. I suggest you use them to answer your personal questions and concerns. This will probably mean that at some point in time you will have to pay for your advice.

Good luck to you and your family.

 

[t74]

I am surprised that you have not heard of families who are willing to sacrifice for the good of their family members - allowing each members to choose for themselves to immigrate to USA, even if that means splitting up their families.
Kind Regards.

What parent would willingly abandon their children when they have a good life (as evidenced by the father's unwillingness to move because he is highly paid in his home country). The family is not in dire straits and being terrorized and in fear for their lives; they just think they want to move to the US. The father wants to stay in Taiwan for the money and his career. He will likely use his family relationship to move to the US in the future when it is no longer financially advantageous to remain in his home - and look at the US taxpayer to support him in his old age. It is all about the money. By the way, are you intending to support them in the US or do you expect them to apply for US taxpayer support on the basis of the "desertion" of the father, or are you going to support them to 125% of the poverty level as you can be required to do as their sponsor?

The US does not need self-serving immigrants - or ones who endorse fraudulent activities.