• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Tenant's request of getting roommate's boyfriend out...

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

MTD

Junior Member
I'm a landlord from Massachusetts who has three female tenants legally living in one apartment having issues with one of their boyfriends, who happens to be more than "just visiting..."

I have been told by both Female Tenants A & B that Tenant C's boyfriend is not only unwelcome in the place, but has also been freeloading (ex: eating other roommates' food without permission, using the shower, to name just two) for the last few months and being rude and nasty to boot. I didn't even know about this guy until the other day when they complained to me about it! At the time of this post, C is currently away for two months in Europe and she gave her apartment keys to this guy (!!!)... and he's been leeching off the other two women while his girl is away. A & B requested for me to change the locks on the front door to prevent him from coming in, sending him the message that he doesn't live there, and give both ladies peace of mind. After listening to their story, I complied with their request and changed the lock and gave A & B new keys. C will DEFINITELY get her new key when she comes back from her long overseas trip (I will directly hand it to her, not her boyfriend).

Did I do the right thing to change the locks on request? To me, it doesn't seem right for him to be in the apartment on his own - unless his girlfriend who IS the legal tenant is present with him... especially with her roommates there who clearly don't approve of him. I thought she doesn't have the right to hand him the keys to begin with.

A sidenote here is that A & B both lived in the apartment the longest (over two years) while C joined them about 10 months ago, so they get seniority over her in terms of decisions in the apartment if that even matters. Personally I cannot blame the two ladies in this regard.

Any thoughts and/or comments?
 


MTD

Junior Member
I don't have their lease on-hand, but basically I do know that the lease states that no more than three people can live in that apartment, and that anyone not on that lease is prohibited from living there as a tenant/roommate.

Note that I have yet to actually cross paths with this guy, let alone catching him coming and going from that apartment (on his own) like he lives there. If I had, I would have definitely confront him about this issue. I for one don't like extra people illegally living in my building for free.
 

strytus

Junior Member
Looking for some advice following this scenario. As a landlord is it legally possible to evict one without the other two? I'm assuming that these friends have signed their name onto one lease. Would it matter if their names were all on the same lease or on separate lease?
 

moburkes

Senior Member
strytus said:
Looking for some advice following this scenario. As a landlord is it legally possible to evict one without the other two? I'm assuming that these friends have signed their name onto one lease. Would it matter if their names were all on the same lease or on separate lease?
Start your own thread. Thanks!
 

strytus

Junior Member
well i figured that would be kind of senseless, since I would be repeating the exact same situation MTD has stated. basically in MTD's situation, I was just wandering if she can legally evict 1 of the 3 tenants that are all signed on the same lease? I thought that maybe the question could/would be connected. If you think otherwise, I will start a new thread.
 

moburkes

Senior Member
strytus said:
well i figured that would be kind of senseless, since I would be repeating the exact same situation MTD has stated. basically in MTD's situation, I was just wandering if she can legally evict 1 of the 3 tenants that are all signed on the same lease? I thought that maybe the question could/would be connected. If you think otherwise, I will start a new thread.
Senseless, or not. Its the rules!
 

treese

Senior Member
strytus said:
well i figured that would be kind of senseless, since I would be repeating the exact same situation MTD has stated. basically in MTD's situation, I was just wandering if she can legally evict 1 of the 3 tenants that are all signed on the same lease? I thought that maybe the question could/would be connected. If you think otherwise, I will start a new thread.
MTD's situation is not the same as yours. She is dealing with an unauthorized occupant NOT a tenant.

You are dealing with tenants.

What works for MTD will not work for you.
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top