• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Defective Work

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

sunnyside

Junior Member
I hired a licensed landscaper and gardener to fix and replace the sprinkler heads in our front and back yard as well as clean up the yard. The house is a rental. The yard wasn't that messy and just needs a little bit of cleaning. This guy came with 3 helpers. While the 3 are doing the clean up, the boss replaced the sprinkler heads. They worked for 1 hour and charged me $230 for that day. One month later some of the sprinkler heads that he replaced are still not working properly.

I phoned him yesterday and asked him to fix the sprinkler heads again. He said he will come by but don't know when. I asked for a specific day so I can be there to see in person his work. He said he has to check his schedule and hung up on me. I consider this guy my employee and he rudely hung up on his employer (me). Three days ago he sent me a bill for $110. $30 is an additional charge that they added on the day they came to repair the sprinkler system. It wasn't in the original quote they gave me that day. They just added that amount as they see fit. The $80 is for the monthly gardening service which my husband has agreed to pay them each month. I haven't sent him his check yet.

I really feel mad at this gardener for his rude behavior. I just want to fire him now but I still want him to fix the sprinklers. He's licensed by the State of CA and he should guarantee his work. I feel that the $230 he charged me that day was way over the top considering that some of the sprinklers he replaced are still not working right.

I reiterated that I want the sprinklers fixed by Tuesday. If he doesn't show up to fix or replace the sprinkler heads, can I defer the $110 charge he asked me to pay him. Am I still liable to pay him inspite of his defective work that day? And do I owe him the $80 too? I just want to apply the $230 I already paid him for his one month's work on my yard. I just feel this gardener cheated me on his lousy work.What is the name of your state?
 


HomeGuru

Senior Member
I hired a licensed landscaper and gardener to fix and replace the sprinkler heads in our front and back yard as well as clean up the yard. The house is a rental. The yard wasn't that messy and just needs a little bit of cleaning. This guy came with 3 helpers. While the 3 are doing the clean up, the boss replaced the sprinkler heads. They worked for 1 hour and charged me $230 for that day. One month later some of the sprinkler heads that he replaced are still not working properly.

I phoned him yesterday and asked him to fix the sprinkler heads again. He said he will come by but don't know when. I asked for a specific day so I can be there to see in person his work. He said he has to check his schedule and hung up on me. I consider this guy my employee and he rudely hung up on his employer (me). Three days ago he sent me a bill for $110. $30 is an additional charge that they added on the day they came to repair the sprinkler system. It wasn't in the original quote they gave me that day. They just added that amount as they see fit. The $80 is for the monthly gardening service which my husband has agreed to pay them each month. I haven't sent him his check yet.

I really feel mad at this gardener for his rude behavior. I just want to fire him now but I still want him to fix the sprinklers. He's licensed by the State of CA and he should guarantee his work. I feel that the $230 he charged me that day was way over the top considering that some of the sprinklers he replaced are still not working right.

I reiterated that I want the sprinklers fixed by Tuesday. If he doesn't show up to fix or replace the sprinkler heads, can I defer the $110 charge he asked me to pay him. Am I still liable to pay him inspite of his defective work that day? And do I owe him the $80 too? I just want to apply the $230 I already paid him for his one month's work on my yard. I just feel this gardener cheated me on his lousy work.What is the name of your state?
**A: the answer is NO.
 

sunnyside

Junior Member
**A: can you understand directions?
Well, excuse me!! I have a college degree and no need to be crass and rude. This is the reason why I always hesitate in posting questions in this forum. People gets so salty in their response. I just had it with you people who have this "holier than thou" attitude. Reality check, "Home Guru", you're nothing in my book. I'd rather pay a lawyer who can treat me with respect. And you "Home Guru" are a very disrespectful person.
 

Rexlan

Senior Member
Pretty rough talk I must say.

The answer is still no. You can not withhold payment for a service performed because your feel a prior service performed was defective. They are not NOT related and you do not know if the original work was defective, just your opinion.

You asked 3 questions ... not 4 and you have a bad attitude. You may be better served going to your attorney instead of here as you said.

4 people to your place plus parts and travel .... $230. What's your beef about that? Aren't they entitled to make a living too? Now you want the guy to come back for free because you're unhappy. He can't just leave his helpers at home.

Based on your attitude here I can see why he hung up on you .... click!
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
data-ad-format="auto">
Top