Response from MARSOC RSAS
I recently e-mailed the Marine Corps in regards to this thread about a month ago. This is the response I got regarding this young man Trisstan (the OP). Take it for what it's worth.
The legal advice involved here I believe is for a Marine to understand when to go to his/her command and when not.
___________________________________________________________
I wish things like this didn't happen but unfortunately it does from time to
time. I'm not trying to defend these Marines supposed actions, but having
known Marines who have been killed in Iraq and Afghanistan, I can see how
there were a lot of Marines in that unit who would be more then a little
upset over what this young man may or may not have said. Combine that with
getting promoted to an equal rank of proven warriors after just arriving at
a recently returned unit although no fault of his own, didn't help and I'm
sure there were some irritated Marines over this. All things combined added
up to a bad situation for this young man. I could write for days on this
subject but I'll leave it at this; In the average Marines mind there is a
fine line between going to your command and not going to your command for
help. In this case he made a poor decision and should have gone to his
command and brought this situation to light. I doubt his seniors (PltSgt,
Pltcmdr, 1stSgt) made any comments to him about hurting him if they weren't
so senior. We as senior leadership look at things objectively when it comes
to leading our Marines. We would not have the kid already found guilty
before bringing all involved together and getting the whole story. This type
of situation is terrible for a units morale and combat effectiveness. It
would not only be in the Marines best interest but also the units to squash
something like that as soon as possible. You know the old saying "There's
your side of the story, there's my side of the story, and the truth lies
somewhere in between" So with that said, I'd say sure, it happens, but to
the degree that this young man states his senior leadership acted, no, I
don't think it does.
-----Original Message-----
From: ******@***.com [mailto:******@***.com]
Sent: Wednesday, September 12, 2007 20:05
To: MSOS A&S
Subject: MARSOC RSAS Inquiry
Civ jack jatsy has submitted an inquiry for the MARSOC RSAS Staff.
Civ jatsy's Information:
Name/Rank: jatsy Civ jack
MOS: 0331
Unit: 2/2/2
Phone: ***-***-****
Time On Station: 3
A/S To Attend: read
E-mail: ******@***.com
Civ jatsy writes:
https://forum.freeadvice.com/showthread.php?t=376709
Please read this thread. Is this true? Is it true that Marines are
behaving this badly?